[Resolved]  The Institute Of Chartered Accountants Of India — complain

dear sir
my chartered account is misleading me i want to complaint
so please tell me concern department that i can complaint

Respected Sir / Mam,

I agree to the above complaint coz this is very true statement, that the management of ICAI is giving the result very minimum in percentage. I am also giving the exams (PE-II) from last 3 years & my exams were going very good, but I failed to pass the exam once. Thousands of students are suffering from this condition & after watching the result they got very upset & demoralise. After giving 3-4 years to one exam no option is left for any student to go back. This is a very serious situation for students to pass the time. And they also do not give the result on time, always they declare the result after 2-3 days of the proposed date. This is really too rediculus & shameful for the management & after 2-3 days they declare the result in evening around 8-9 pm. They give time on net 2 pm, then 6 pm then 8 pm and after that they always extend the time but do not declare the result. What is this.

I request you to kindly look into the matter & give me positive response.

Thanks

dear sir/madam,
we live in usa and we sold our property in india. so for that we hired ca. and he promised me and my sister who was co owner of this inherited property, that he will help us repatriate our money from
sell of our house back in usa. for that he charged us 20000 rs. and we paid him in all good faith.
we came back to usa and started repat process.
and sent him so many emails, called him always. he would promise us he will do it. and he is very busy.
but nothing happened.we felt he cheated us.
so we were fortunate and found very honest another ca who helped us with all the paperwork.
so we feel like we want our money back from our cheater ca and file complaint against him.
so we would like to know how do we do that? all the procedure. we would appreciate your help in this matter.we still have all the proof.thank you so much

Yes I agree that this the normal practice of CA's to keep client hanged for no reason and one fine day he will give a magical solution to problem and make you feel that he is a god for you and ending with demanding money in return of it.

The CA I have worked with for last few years is incompetent, unprofessional and basically a weasel. He is engaged in all sort of dirty practices and want his clients to be involved in such practices so that he can blackmail them later (Be very careful when your CA propose some corrupt practices for saving a little bit taxe) He also exploits his staff (associates etc.). I changed my CA recently...let us see how the new one turns out.

Company Registration Firm - Fraudulently making money in the name of company registration

http://www.emindkpo.com/

http://www.emindkpo.com/

Company Registration Firm - Fraudulently making money in the name of company registration

Mr Venkatasubramanya from EmindKPO is a cheater and his firm is involved in cheating many in Bangalore and involved in some fraud cased. I will suggest all of you not to come under this firms soft talks. I have lost about 50K in the name of company registration and the guy who run the business never comes to office and hidden from all authorities. I am not sure how the ICAI is not taking any action on such fraudulent members of ICAI.

If anyone can suggest me how I can file a compliant in ICAI and the regional offices of ICAI regarding this firm and the CA

Sir, I just give Capt Dec.2014 attempt and then when results are announced I check my results it will be same as my last attempt results which I not cleared. So plaza sir can you resolve my problem.plz sir.

Sir, I just give Cpt Dec.2014 attempt and then when results are announced I check my results it will be same as my last attempt results which I not cleared. So plz sir can you resolve my problem.plz sir.

Complaint against icai - reg. Illegal termination of article training service

Respected sir,

The guidelines alongwith regulatory provisions supplied to us alongwith forms of article training by icai sale counters were duly complied with and on the basis of which icai accepted our form no 102 and form no 103.

After careful checking and considering abovesaid form no 102 and form no 103 icai accepted the same without any objections because they are according to the regulatory provisions of icai.

The icai also issued/sent to me the identity card of my article training according to form no 102 and form no 103.

The said identity card signed by my principal member alongwith counter signed by the officials of icai alongwith their seal.

According to form no 102 and form no 103 the period of my article training starts from 1/4/2009 to 31/7/2012.

Similarly the period of my article training stated on my identity card starts from 1/4/2009 to 31/7/2012.

After successful completion of my article training, form no 108 was signed by principal on 11/8/2012 for the period of article training stated on said form no 108 starts from 1/4/2009 to 31/7/2012 and and the said form no 108 dispatched to icai on 21/8/2012 i.E. Well in time.

The icai illegally terminated my article training on 3/7/2014 with effect from 10/10/2010 and refused to issue me article training completion certificate without my fault.

I sent morethan hundred emails to the secretary, president, e-sahayata portal but neither icai is replying nor passing any orders on my abovesaid pleadings inspite of fact a brief note was put up before secretary for final decisions but even icai refused to provide me the copy of said brief note put up by the concerned staff, reply of concerned branch on said brief note put up on my behalf before secretary and the orders passed by the hon'ble secretary on my pleadings and as such icai destroys my life from 31/7/2012 without my faults only to cover up the illegal working of their branches.

Best regards.

Tanvi dhiman
Registration no nro0172813 student c.A. Final

Dear Sir/ Mam,

I completely agree to the above statements. This is the strategy of these professional institutes to hold the results of the students and harass them at various instances. They charge fee but never give the satisfying result.. Students who do hard work in every attempt receive the result as he/she never studied for it. Very disappointed with the attitude!!

dear sir
my chartered account is misleading me i want to complaint
so please tell me concern department that i can complaint

Mr Rohit Hari (Membership No: 076336) of Rohit Hari & Associates (Registration No: 007991C) 11, Astley Hall, Dehra Dun, was not a practising chartered accountant between[protected], with zero CPE hours during this period. He claimed to hold an active COP, but alongside was doing business, besides being a partner in a firm thereby drawing a share in profit as well as a salary from m/s R.B.Hamer & Company, 11 Astley Hall, Dehra Dun. Mr Rohit Hari, in his income tax returns, (PAN - ABCPH9063R) showed no income as a chartered accountant yet fraudulently implicated an 87 years man in a civil suit claiming to be a practising chartered accountant. Administrator www.icai.org - Kindly look into this matter urgently and penalize this member.

Sir,
Institute has issued a notification dated 15/03/2015,
in which it says that the student who attempts extra questions in exam,
then which questions he first solved the marks of such questions are only given,
it means if later questions answers got extra marks then such marks will not be given,
i want to know where i register complaint against such notification.
are these notifications are binding on students
please help me

Dear sir with respectfully i want to state you that since feb 2014 i am regularly writting to president of india and prime minister modi ji about tax evasion by mohd iftekhar m d of ruksh group of companies by not recording of scrap sales and empty drums of chemicals evam recording of fake vouchers o[censored]nregistered labour charges since the inception of group companies today morning i saw in hindustan news paper about survey of income tax department in leadership of deputy director shree k k mishra ji three teams has raided in his four premises situated at jajmau kanpur and banthar unnao that found major irregularities and tax evasion in carores please arrange to make an high label monitoring of search that can be managed by accused mohd iftekhar with mediation of his chartered accountant swaran singh munjaal sudheendra jain and raj narain tiwari and associates jagdish chandra the tax evasion amount rupees around 40 carores as he is also presently chairman of regional council of leather exports he can use his contacts for hiding tax evasion as he is using thus generated black money to funding of madarsas and masjids where getting sheltered anti national activists kindly arrange to survey of all other major players of leather industry that is 95 percent managed and owned by muslims those are silently helping to anti national activists by donating to madarsas and masjids as my accounting and taxation financial services to his firms company the dues rupees 25 lacs is still not paid by him kindly arrange to order his bankar union bank of india birhana road kanpur for freezing his firms bank current account [protected] of ruksh exim private limited [protected] ruksh international [protected] rs 25 lacs and transfer to my savings account [protected] with punjab national bank mall road kanpur in this regard i have written to pmo vide their reference nopmopg oblic eobilic 2016 oblic 0033511dated31jan2016and pmopg oblic eoblic 2016oblic 0037681dated3feb2016 that was forwarded to ms anna ray joint secretary department of financial services and mr jawahar lal deputy secretary chief minister uttar pradesh respectively mohd iftekhar has short paid custom duty on import 2 aluminium drums by under invoicing from foshan tai trading co dated 14 jan 2012 invoice made usd 81435.00 while payment made for this vide contract 111465.00 in advance through union bank of india birhana road branch kanpur thus custom duty on usd 30000 short paid

Seriously what's wrong with CA final results??? In my own result which was declared today, I got conflicting results. I am not complaining because I flunked today as I have enough courage to handle failure multiple times but it's because there is something definitely wrong with the system of results. I cleared a subject where I had fared bad but flunked in one of the subjects where I was expecting exemption. I don't feel like applying for revaluation as I personally have lost faith in The genuineness of ICAI.

I have no intention to malign the reputation of the organisation but icai must understand the plight of students like us. Also i m writing this because of the confidence in the amount of efforts I have put in for CA exams

Hello sir,        
My name is neha kabra. My CRO no. 0319738.
Paper1 examption was received in Nov.2014 .this examption up to vailld 3 rd attempt ie may 2016.
I give exam may 2016 and get score in paper 2 above 60 marks ie 71.
I give exam Nov 2016 but result show paper 2 is absent.
So my query is paper 2 is exemption is availability or not. Because show my online result is absent I thought this paper is exempt so not given this paper

Based on the stats below, none of these complaints have been resolved? That is not possible because all the CAs I takes to say that ICAI takes its code of ethics very seriously.
It will be nice to know how many got resolved.