Medanta The Medicity Complaints & Reviews

I visited Medanta Gurgaon for the treatment of my father. I started with Dr Ashok Vaid and later case was transferred to Dr Nagender Sharma for further treatment. On perusal of there website, there is no mention of any Dr Nagender Sharma on there site, as such the credentials of the Dr can not be verified by me. May I request you to direct the hospital to update the details of the doctor at the earliest.

My father mr. Sultan ali (Mm[protected] underwent ct scan on 17/4/2017 at medanta, reported by dr sonal krishan. The report of the scan mentioned four residual tumors in liver. We went to interventional radiology deptt in medanta where the scan was reviewed and we were told that there are five tumors in liver and the missing fifth tumor was shown to us on ct images on the screen. The ir deptt went ahead and ablated all five lesions (Thank god the ir doctors evaluated the scan themselves and did not rely on dr sonal krishan's report).
This is gross medical negligence to miss a tumor in a patient. We request the hospital to refund the money charged to us for the ct scan as it has been reported wrongly.

Dr. Nitin Sood is extremly bad. My cousin, aged 28, went for leukimea AML M5 treatment. Doctors, specially Sood could not identitfy that he got sepsis. No treatment for sepsis was started and he died in a couple of days. He had developed blisters on skins and was operated upon without giving any antibiotics for sepsis. He vomitted blood within hours of operation. Later in his death cause, they simply mentioned sepsis as the reason.

Patient Name: Pratibha Sinha
Patient Id: 10189660

We wanted to get done bental procedure as advised by respective doctor (in and out) to get rid of aortic dissection type A. We got a package of rupees 6.50 Lakhs from Medanta hospital to do bental procedure and I authorized for same procedure. But during billing process Medanta hospital stated that Mendata has done two different procedures.
1. Bental Procedure

2. Hemi Arch repair

As I have authorized for only bental procedure but Hemi Arch repair also been done without prior my consultation. Now these 2 different procedures, bring some doubts in my mind
1. Whether do the doctor of Mendata hospital failed to do proper diagnose about patient?

2. If it is not failure of doctor’s diagnosis, then how doctor not informed me about this process before doing the operation. As they have not demanded any fee for this beforehand.

3. As Doctor has done repair of Hemi Arch but why not its replacement

4. Also, Doctor has not advised me about benefit of repair or replacement of Hemi Arch.

5. On what basis, doctor identified to do Hemi Arch repair not replacement.

6. What is the success rate of hemi arch repair and replacement and what would be life of these two?

With all these doubts, I would like to say that What package was demanded for Bental procedure has been paid before operation with all remaining by us.

Package of bental was 6.50 lakhs and later demanded for another 2-3 lakhs extra more than the initial package. Now we don’t have any remains to pay these extra rupees 2-3 lakhs.

We do please advise you to eradicate the lacuna which are obvious from above. We do praise the hospital staff for their well warm welcome and support they provided at emergency.

We are not able to pay more than the package amount of rupees 6.50 lakhs.

Dr prathiba dewan oncology is a fake doctor never visit her please my humble request, i visit to her with my mom with all her evidence reports and all without properly examing she refer us for biopsy then when she unable to find anything specific she told us she assuming that patient have cancer just because she dint feel like eating and she losing wait so she assumed she means my mom have cancer really nonsense and disgusting where else we under go through her operation at her local hospital just an tumour operation. Which she was telling probably be done within 8 to 10 lacs that just happened with 1 lac . Idiot doctor

Hi This is Radheshyam my patient name is Dhaneshwar saw my patient is in ICU however i want to know the status about my patient the recceptionist not recieving my call and also the behaviour was not good.

I already submitted my contact no, and they are u mobile is switch off thats absolutely not correct.

Could you please do the action as soon as possible.
This is my right to know the status of patient who is already in ICU

Thanks in advance!

Best regards, '
Radheshyam

Hi sir,
I got mail from my health insurance, please provide me to the missing documents. I am attaching the same mail at the bottom of this mail.

Dear Sir/Madam,
We are in receipt of your claim documents (Claim no: 90258159—00) pertaining to Health Insurance policy (#[protected] and on evaluation, have found that the Following information/documents are not available with us.

PLEASE PROVIDE ALL INDOOR CASE PAPER RECORD WITH DOCTOR AND NURSE NOTES DURING HOSPITALIZATION.

PLEASE PROVIDE TEMPERATURE AND VITAL CHART DETAILS.

My name is Dr.Abbas Ali Khatai. I am an Emergency physician. My father; Mr.Shawkat Ali Khatai is admitted right now in room no:4832 at Medanta medicity Gurgaon. He is a post complication of CABG which was discoverd two days back and now admitted for an urgent angiography. I am sorry to inform you that this has been a very painful and alarming experience for me. I am a specialist at a NABH and a JCI accredited hospital; which makes me well aware of the protocols and procedures. For starters; the entire situation was very emotional for the patient and the family; but being educated and in the medical field; we accepted it and went ahead with the angiography. We were promised the best cardiologist for the procedure which was very kind of our admitting ctvs consultant. As you know an angiography is an awake procedure; my father was alert and aware the entire time.A junior trainee was given the procedure unsupervised!!! It doesnt matter to me how many angios he has done in his life; but a complication post CABG should have been done by a senior consultant.How can you let a trainee do a procedure unsupervised?? The trainee gave it multiple attempts, voicing his disgust and joking with the nurses; causing severe pain to my father. My father had soo much pain that he went into bradycardia (I will specifically mention the heart rate-32!). This was followed by a frantic call by the trainee to the senior consultant who came in and did the procedure. Also to add that trainee admitting out loudly that he hasn't studied the procedure; "maine ye padha nahi". I am flabbergasted and outraged!!! .This was the last thing I would have expected from a brand that 'Medanta medicity' is. Adding insult to injury; all this informatiom and complications were hidden from us by Dr.Nagendra singh chouhan. One hour post procedure my dad loat vision in his right eye; after alerting the duty doctor, we were informed that there is no ophthalmologist to examine him. After almost 24hours an ophthalmologist examined my father and declared that he has a cilio-retinal occlusion and he will not get hIs vision back. I am extremely hurt and broken. I cant bare to see my father. This complication should not have happened.it was a huge medical negligence. The cardiologist did not apologise or explain himself.

A routine knee replacement surgery of my uncle at Medanata Hospital by Dr. RajGopal took his life. He was in coma for 11 months and passed away after a long fight. During his stay in the hospital ICU nurses and doctors were rude and negligent. They made too many mistakes. Peg Tube replacement caused peritonitis. His shoulder was dislocated by the staff.
Dr. RajGopal does not inform the patients about the complications of the knee replacement surgery. You are made to believe it is a routine surgery. But the patient is at a serious risk of fat embolism leading to lung failure, brain damage, coma, kidney failure and death. You sign a fine print form at the last minute. It's a FRAUD! Indians are being tricked, the doctors are becoming billionaires and some o[censored]s are dying.

माननीय
श्री नरेश त्रेहान जी
मुझे यह देखकर आज काफी दुःख हुआ की आपका मेदांता हॉस्पिटल इरवा राँची झारखण्ड में यह देखा गया की किसी भी फ्लोर में विडियो (C. C. Tv) कैमरा नही है और न ही हर फ्लोर में urinal (Gents/ladies) की ब्यस्था हैi यह सोचा नही जा सकता है की ऐसी बुनियादी सुविधा पर मेदांता के प्रबंधन का ध्यान क्यों नही गयाi हम चाहते है की मेदांता की गरिमा बरकरार रहे चुकी इस हॉस्पिटल से आपका नाम जुड़ने के साथ धीरे धीरे अपनी छवी बन रही हैi
धन्यवाद् i
विशेष सूचनार्थ
देवराज सिंह
D. S. Complex
Thana chowk,
Ramgarh cantt.
Jharkhand
मोबाइल न. - [protected]

To whomsoever it may concern.
My name is Dr.Abbas Ali Khatai. I am an Emergency physician from a family of 21 doctors with our own hospital in kashmir. My father; Mr.Shawkat Ali Khatai is admitted right now in room no:4832 at your esteemed center. He is a post complication of CABG which was discoverd and now admitted for an urgent angiography. I am sorry to inform you that this has been a very painful and alarming experience for me....

I went medanta to know about the eye laser treatment and my experience was bad there. No one cared about the patient but were busy in there other stuff.. After 1 hr i got my eyes checked by one of the junior doctor, who doesn't provide me proper details about the treatment and said me to come after 2 weeks.. Its just not a right behavior to treat the patient who came so far to get treatment. Also, some areas of the hospitals were not hygienic.

I also have bad experience with medanta. as i heard about cancer specialist dr. rajeev agarwal. i went there to discuss reports of my sister which shows that she is in cancer.
We paid consultaion fees 900 and entered in the cabin.
My two brother in law were with me. dr. rajeev agarwal asked for reports. then i showed all of them. he said that surgery is the last option.
And asked for our input.
Then i started and...

😢Eye Opening Incident of Medical Fraud😢

Forwarded as received...

In response to the write-up by Nandini Sinha on Medanta, my unit offr Col RK Rahul has the following to say. It's his personal experience :

बहुत अच्छा article लिखा नंदिनी जी आपने। बड़े- बड़े नामी hospitals का तो बुरा हाल है। मैं February 2015 में Gurgaon के एक बहुत बड़े multi speciality हॉस्पिटल "MEDANTA-The Medicity" में अपनी Heart problem को लेकर Dr.Naresh Trehan से मिला। Rs.800/- उनकी consultation fees जमा की। Dr. Trehan ने मेरे Lucknow के records और पुरानी reports देख कर कहा कि आपके 3 valve ख़राब हैं। इन्हें replace करना होगा।खर्चा बताया 7.5 लाख रुपये। मेरा 2D echo test भी किया गया और तब भी यही बताया गया। Medanta के ही एक और Director हैं Dr. Kasliwaal. हम लोग उनसे लखनऊ के एक उनके परिचित के reference से मिले। तब Dr Kasliwal ने Dr. Trehan से बात करी और हमको 5.75 लाख जमा करने को कहा। हम लोगों ने जमा कर दिए और admit हो गए। check-ups start हो गए। 12 March की date दे दी गयी surgery की। 11 March की रात में जो लिस्ट release की गयी, उसमें मेरा नाम नहीं था। अगली सुबह जब drs round पर आये तो पता चला कि आपके urine में infection है, उसका treatment होगा तब surgery होगी। treatment में सुबह-शाम antibiotic injections लगने थे। 6 दिन का course था। Medanta का room 8000/- per day का था। हम लोगों ने discharge ले लिया और बाहर guest house में रहकर treatment लेने लगे। 5 दिन बाद मेरे एक Delhi के मित्र ने कहा कि एक बार cross check के लिए कहीं और भी echo करा लो। हम लोग Delhi के National Heart Institute में गए और वहां 2D echo कराया 3000/- में। उन लोगों ने बताया कि आपका 01 valve खराब है। उसकी सर्जरी करके replace की cost बतायी 3.75 लाख। हम लोग बहुत confused हो गए क्योंकि Medanta में हमारा 5.75 जमा था। हम लोग Dr.Kasliwal से दोबारा मिले और उनको National Heart की echo report दिखाई। Namrata ji, believe me, Dr. Kasliwal सर पकड़ कर बैठे रहे, उनका पूरा staff करीब 8-9 लोग उस समय उनके चैम्बर में थे, Dr. करीब 30-40 सेकण्ड के pause के बाद बोले कि - "यार मैं तो Trehan से पहले दिन से कह रहा हूँ कि तेरा एक ही valve खराब है, लेकिन क्या करें, हम लोगों पर इतना pressure रहता है।" Namrata ji, I was shocked to hear this. उनका सारा staff उनकी और हमारी शकल देख रहा। उनके चेहरे पर शर्मिंदगी और मेरे चेहरे पर असंतोष के भाव थे। मैंने कहा dr साहब मैं आपके पास फलाँ व्यक्ति के reference से आया था। कम से कम आप उसी का सोच कर मेरे से ईमानदारी रखते। खैर, हम लोगों ने बाद में अपने पैसे वहां से वापस लिए तो 80000/- काट कर हमको पैसे वापस किये गए। 80000/- hospital ने अपने expenses कt.v. gकाट लिए, जो हमारी जाँचे हुई थी और 4 दिन हम लोग 8 star हॉस्पिटल में रहे थे। फाइनली, हमने अपनी surgery Fortis Escorts में कराई Dr. Z. S.Meherwal ने करी। इस प्रकार से बड़े hospitals मरीज़ को cheat करते हैं। यह मेरा अपना व्यक्तिगत अनुभव रहा जो कि अत्यन्त दुखदायी है। इतना बड़ा hospital, इतने बड़े नाम वाला डॉक्टर और ये हाल !!!

This is not a hospital. This is a business house where doctors are just taking money and not bothered about patients. One of the gaurd told me sir in this hospital when doctors ask for sample to test. We throw those sample in dustbin without even testing them. And those tests comes in billing. Nurses literally beat patients in icu in absence of patient's relatives. My grandmother was admitted there from last 25 days and she went there on her own legs but they killed my grandmother. When i called the chairman of medanta dr. Rajiv parakh i abused him and at the same time i took an advocate from high court on a conference call. Dr. Naresh trehan often comes to delhi high court as they have killed so many people in last 1 year. So many cases are filed against them but it's all fine with them coz they are safe coz of mr. Chotala. They use the same treatment. Dialyses, ventilator. I have seen so many patients on ventilator who were dead but still they were on ventilator coz medanta has a different policy. They say keep the patient in hospital untill and unless their family doesn't sell their house and pay us atleast 40-50 lacs. They killed an 28 years old guy coz one of the foreigner family needed kidney on urgent basis. And medanta is such an amazing business house where they knew that from foreigner patient they will get money in dollars. So they killed that guy. One of the family told me my son is on ventilator from last 2 months. I mean come on doctors don't you have family? When i called dr. Rajiv parakh and i started abusing, he was fine. When i asked him if you true and life saver then take me to an icu and show my the alive patients on ventilator. You are keeping dead bodies on ventilator just to make money. Doctors in medanta are on percentage, there is no salary. Thats why their focus is on making more n more money. Dr. Rajiv parakh, dr. Naresh trehan, dr. Sanjay mittal, rumneek kaur. Kindly check medanta public review before you take you love one in this hellcity. They are not doctors they are criminals and doing crime openly.

My father had a surgery on 12 may, 16 and room was to be allotted at 7pm and they made patient wait for 4 hrs. Also the doctor didn't gave the review about surgery. The management staff keeps on making fool of customers and make them move around for the discharge process. The discharge process takes more that 5 hrs. Also the services were very poor. Please make sure that future patients don't suffer the same thing....

Respected sir, there is no doubt that your hospital is very good . Because everything in this hospital is handled properly except the hospitality of this hospital. Actually the thing is there was a water supply problem in the washroom in my room and i complained 2 times in house keeping but nobody came to see the problem. This is the worst experience i have ever had.

Medanta-the medicity
"naam bade or darshan chote"
High attitude of the security staff.
Rude unclear n poorly trained (but trained in stealing things). on 27feb night at the check in point the lady guard damini took out 80k from my mother's purse when she was checking it.. when my mumma noticed her purse in the nxt morning she was shocked.. when we complained to the concerned authorities about the lady guard... they straight away refused to call her in the hospital... they said "hum uski neend kharab ni kar sakte"
Staff member kuldeep meri behen pr chillaya.. he dont knw how to talk to girls.
All the security members kuldeep pankaj dinesh were with that lady.
Mr. tehran this is destroying ur image.. pls take a look at it

It was known as one of the best hospitals however when u need any info first point of contact doesn't know anything. Always ask me to talk to different people like doctor, billing, Confirmation etc Patient was suppose to have surgery at 1 pm (didn't offer anything from 12 am previous night)since he is on insulin was made to wait till 10 pm and operation didn't happen. 2nd time again he was without food for 10 hrs. If ppl who take care of patients don't know themselves the criticality, who to trust for treatment. On top of that bill is 2 lakes its better to take the patient to govt hospital and do the same without spending a penny and still get the similar type of treatment

Dear Sir/Madam I am Anwar Hussain from Gurgaon, I was taken appointment from Dr Rajneesh Kapoor for treatment of my Father on 24.12.2015 due to cardiac attack on 14.12.2015. As per Dr Rajneesh Kapoor and Team they had suggested me for Angiography to find out the reason of heart attack and % of blockage if any. They had offered me a day care package of Angiography for INR 11000/- and ensured that all procedure shall be completed within 4 Hr. I said o.k. to proceed and paid INR 11000/-. Examination team has taken all sample for test and handover to patient to Cath Lab without finding the Glucose level in Normal condition. During the Cath Lab procedure glucose level of Patient was 35 mg/dL. and they has started the procedure. During the procedure time patient has lost the confidence and got frustrated and mentally disturb due to low glucose level and shown lots of pain in body, Vomiting complain, Sweating etc. Situation was out of control and patient got violence due to mentally disturbance. Even patient has lost control on his senses and done motion on bet at Cath Lab area Immediately I have requested from Dr to cancel the procedure and Dr has shifted patient in ICU. immediately Nursing team has measure sugar level in ICU and It was aprox 32 mg/dL. Dr was also surprised that how examination team has given clearance to cath lab for angiography. After 2 Hr Dr has met with me suggested that we have to wait for normal Glucose level and we has cancle for angiography to do by Today. It will be done on tomorrow meantime you have to admit to patient for some observation. I asked the question from Dr Rajneesh Kapoor that tomorrow is 25th Dec (X'mas) will you be available. Dr replied me, Yes. I will be in Cat Lab during procedure. In mid night 1.00 AM ICU Team has shifted to Patient on Bed No 5910 on 9th Floor and taken sample for some common test. On 25th Dec 2015 Cath lab had called to Patient for Angiography with complete set-up. before the starting of test procedure Cath Lab team has called to me and told we can't do this test at today due to some abnormalities in Test reports. Cath technician has advised me to Meet Dr Mayank who was on duty that time. Dr Mayank has told me that we are sorry today we can't do angiography due to abnormalities in creatinine level it is 2. So we can't do angiography, It can damage kidney. I had tried to contact Dr Rajneesh, and he was not in hospital due to holiday and Dr Mayank has told that he has already contact with him. He has told to wait. You need to wait for next day. We had also informed to Neurology team and they will check to Patient and advise for next procedure. When I returned on ward i told to ward care TL, What is next procedure. TL has informed me that Dr Rajneesh has hold angiography for today. You have to wait for tomorrow. Immediately I told to TL That i need to talk Dr Rajneesh, He called to him and told me you can meet with him on 3rd Floor. I told him Dr Rajneesh is not in hospital today then how you are saying that he is in hospital. TL has replied me that you can meet Dr Mayank. Dr Rajneesh has left the hospital. I was surprised what he was saying? Neurology dr has visited in ward at afternoon and seen all report and told me that we have to do one more test for creatinine level and will informed to Dr Rajneesh. Dr Rajneesh can have to take decision because we can control the creatinine level later. I asked to neurologist that which day you have done test for creatinine level. Neurologist has replied at yesterday on 24.12.2015. I was surprised. I asked neurologist the how yesterday you were doing angiography yesterday when creatinine level is not control. Neurologist has replied that we were considering you past report which was done on 14.12.2015. Which was done in UP during heart attack time. In evening on dated 25.12.2.015. Nurse has told me that we have required to do USG for kidney check-up and complete KFT as advised by Dr. I was surprised that I came for angiography and they had started for kidney treatment and admitted unnecessary to my Father. I have taken budget of 11K and now I dont know what is billing amount even I asked from TL for estimate but he is not giving the estimate. I am not able to pay much money. All mistake has done by Medanta's employee and increase my bills. Now I am very upset and decided to go for legal. How they can do these kinds of negligence. Please support me for right judgement. Anwar Hussain