Edelweiss
1.3
Submit a Complaint
24
COMPLAINTS

Edelweiss Complaints & Reviews

D
Aug 10, 2021
Report
Copy

Address: Delhi

I posses 2 DP ID with Edelweiss. Latest one is active since 2020 and other one is more older and inoperative since 2018, however both are active as per CDSL data.

I am frequently requesting for DIS slip of my older DP ID but it's been over a month now and I haven't received any positive response till date.
Helpful
Found this helpful?
Write a comment
Report
Copy

Post your Comment

    I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
    code
    By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
    Submit
    S
    sethirocking
    from Noida, Uttar Pradesh
    Sep 2, 2020
    Report
    Copy

    Moratorium was requested on the Edeleweiss loan account.However they have debited 2 EMIs in 10 days.They have been presenting NACH several times due to which I have been charged NACH Return charges from my bank.The next EMI date is 5/9/20 .I had kept the money for my daily needs and they have debited it.
    Dear Customer,

    We regret the inconvenience caused. Request you to write to us at [protected]@edelweissfin.com from your registered email-id or call our toll-free number [protected] (Mon-Fri) and we will assist you further.

    Regards,
    Team Edelweiss
    Helpful
    1 other people found this review helpful
    1 found this helpful
    1 Comment
    Report
    Copy

    Post your Comment

      I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
      code
      By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
      Submit
      A
      anilrbk
      from Bengaluru, Karnataka
      Jun 27, 2020
      Report
      Copy

      Website: edelweiss.in

      Recently they increased brokerage for my account. After I asked to financial advisor she suggested a plan of 10, 000 with rate of 0.02 for intraday and delivery and amount will deduct from this 10, 000 amount.
      Once the plan was activated, neither they deducted as per brokerage plan and they deducted money from both place i. e. From bank AC and from 10, 000. Their system is stupid and nowadays there is no one to support due to covid19.
      Jun 30, 2020
      Updated by anilrbk
      I don't see why it has been resolved. Can anyone help?
      Jun 30, 2020
      Updated by anilrbk
      Hi Issue is Still not resolved.

      I was told below benefits for ADB plan costing 10, 000+18% GST
      1. No min. brokerage charge of like 25rs.
      2. Brokerage charge will also be 0.02.
      3. Brokerage will be deducted from this 10, 000.

      Next day when i executed 3 trade and 25x3 was deducted from 10, 000 as well as from Cash Balance that i had in my account.

      It took at least 3-4 days to digest them that there is some issue and due to that brokerage amount got debited from both the place by our Financial advisor. Now she has raised the issue but i still didn't received any confirmation that the amount will be refunded or something.

      Now i don't have patient and would eagerly waiting for the resolution.

      Thanks & Regards
      Helpful
      2 other people found this review helpful
      2 found this helpful
      Write a comment
      Report
      Copy

      Post your Comment

        I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
        code
        By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
        Submit
        N
        Nkhlporwal30
        Jun 26, 2020
        Report
        Copy

        Website: Www.edelweiss.in

        One of Share AMFL I BOUGHT before, , today I see on edelweiss application and website it showing different previous close shows 6.74 and on BSE WEBSITE it showing 6.57 previous close. I have attached screenshots of today as u can check
        +5 photos
        Hi,
        We are sorry you are facing some problems. Please help us with your contact number, we will have the team connect with you at the soonest.
        Regards,
        Team Edelweiss
        Helpful
        Found this helpful?
        1 Comment
        Report
        Copy

        Post your Comment

          I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
          code
          By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
          Submit
          T
          Taritkumardas
          from Bengaluru, Karnataka
          Jun 5, 2020
          Report
          Copy

          Brokerage plan imposed on me without my confirmation - cip[protected], my dmat account 60050839, edelweiss not responded my complaint properly nor refund brokerage charges to my ledger. Kindly approach
          Hi Tarit,
          Our Relationship Manager Mr. Suresh has spoken to you and shared the required details related to the brokerage.
          - Team Edelweiss
          Helpful
          1 other people found this review helpful
          1 found this helpful
          1 Comment
          Report
          Copy

          Post your Comment

            I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
            code
            By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
            Submit
            A
            animesh96
            Mar 13, 2020
            Report
            Copy

            Address: 201010

            The edelweisse has done fraud and done transactionn without customer knowledge. They have sell shares @234 where as market is 241 or 239. This makes us loss. Further transaction has not been informed to me nor i had received any margin call money payment call yesterday.

            My rm - sumedha is also completely unaware of this transaction. Girish - head of section and himanshu-head of north is least bother about it.

            Kindly take this as formal complaint.

            Client code : epn0010251
            Dear Animesh,

            We regret the inconvenience caused. We request you to message us your contact details on either of our social media handles. One of our team members will connect with you shortly.

            Regards,
            Team Edelweiss
            Helpful
            1 other people found this review helpful
            1 found this helpful
            1 Comment
            Report
            Copy

            Post your Comment

              I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
              code
              By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
              Submit
              P
              Piyush Parkhe
              from Pune, Maharashtra
              Sep 14, 2019
              Report
              Copy

              I was assured for 3 year no amc and 3 month no brokerage but mr rajan from chakala branch mumbai edelweiss but as soon as he promised he vanished and not responding document submitted in june and account opened in july still the plan has not been activated need strict action against mr rajan as he promised me on behalf of the company but it was no plan existed as such as per my knowledge
              Dear Piyush,
              We regret the inconvenience caused. We understand that our client experience manager has spoken to you and noted down your concern, we will get back shortly.
              Regards,
              Team Edelweiss
              Helpful
              Found this helpful?
              1 Comment
              Report
              Copy

              Post your Comment

                I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                code
                By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                Submit
                S
                SantoshKotiyan
                from Mumbai, Maharashtra
                Aug 7, 2019
                Report
                Copy

                Address: 400089

                Hi,

                Myself santosh kotiyan, one of your very unfortunate customer and my misfortune to be associated with a disgraced brand. Let me start by reminding your tag line “we’re not just any other brokerage firm providing broking services, we believe in being an investment advisor, dedicated to empower our clients to gain from market opportunities and to build long term relationships with them...” such wonderful words. Just wanted to know does anyone in the organisation abide by it. Your guiding principles makes me laugh and at the same time feel cheated by the organisation and it’s representative carrying the tag on their shoulders. I also take this opportunity to remind the team coordinating with customers some of the guiding principles which the company insists and wants to ensure each of its employee is guided by the common vision... But my question is does anybody monitor if it is getting implemented at the ground level. Some of your principles
                1. We will listen to our customers.
                2. We recognise that we need to satisfy the needs, sometimes conflicting, of all stakeholders; shareholders who entrust us with their capital, employees who create the organisation, customers who are the reason we exist and society which has given us the resources and opportunity to create value.
                3. We will be fair to our clients, our employees and all stakeholders.
                4. Our reputation and image is more important than any financial reward.

                None of the above stands true in each of the interactions i had with sushant & akhilesh mapped to my relationship with edelweiss. After multiple calls they would respond and in each of the interactions they have insisted they are doing their best for me but have never addressed my problems by stating it to be company policy or they being helpless at their end. They have gone to the extent o[censored]pdating me that ecl finance & edelweiss broking are 2 different arm and there is no coordination between the two. Despite the fact that both of them sat together the very next day to devise a strategy to counter my allegation when i treated to take them to task for their gross negligence.
                Their lack of coordination and least regards for my pleas have cost me 1300 shares of rbl bank from from my esop loan account due to margin shortfall despite the very fact that i have margin of 10 lac in my trading account. I still don’t understand why was my shares forfeited when on the other had the same organisation had given me a margin of almost 16 lacs in my trading account. I am a middle class investor with a liability of 1cr against my home loan. Anything that hits my investments becomes sensitive and yes i react. I follow up. I try to reach out to everyone who could help. Yes i could get irritating at your end but all i am looking at is resolution. I had complained against akhilesh in my previous communication and his least regards for customer service or customer grievances. He is only visible when business is available or documents to be executed. Then he is an enigma. I had to ask him for statements he would oblige when he is free.in my corresponding case he claims he has been coordinating and updated me for margin money but i beg to differ. He claims he needed not call since there are multiple communication to me on mail. I agree with him but having said that i am trying to coordinate with him for a solution on how do i go about salvaging my shares. He calls the previous night and updates me that my shares will be forfeited tomorrow morning with least concern even after me protesting that i have an broking account with edelweiss with free shares. He kept insisting that he could not help me and that there has been enough warnings given to me and hence he is not in a position to help. The very next day i am shocked to be updated 1300 of my rbl stocks is forfeited and i have lost almost 1/4 of investment to insensitive approach of my relationship managers. Since there was no help coming from akhilesh i tried reaching to my investment manager rahul, i was told he was down with viral fever but tried to coordinate with akhilesh in the instance but there was no support from our undisputed champion of ecl finance ltd. I was advised to approach sushant, investment manger for my portfolio. Here again i need to mention he is a very busy gentleman who is always hard pressed for time and always in meetings for the organisation. He does comes on call after repeated follow up assuming my trading i’d is also part of his portfolio and he can oblige me sometimes. So at times i have been lucky and grateful to him for taking my calls. He says i have been threatening for questioning his ethics to customer service and sheer lack of commitment customer relationship. I am not sure if justice will come of this mail but it is imperative i present my case to the seniors and required to the board members before i take this up with sebi and also look out for legal recourse.
                I am not happy to be associated with edelweiss and has been working on moving my entire portfolio of esop loan as well as my trading account portfolio to other organisation. Until then request you to kindly consider my request to take care of my investment which is purely been built to write off my home loan.

                By the way i take this opportunity to request you send my demat kit and also my loan statements. A hard copy would be appreciated since i hardly get to access my mail account.

                Look forward to your positive update.

                Regards
                Santosh kotiyan
                [protected]
                Dear Santosh,
                We regret the inconvenience caused. We understand that our client experience manager has spoken to you and made a note of your concerns. We will get back to you shortly.
                Regards,
                Team Edelweiss
                Dear Santosh,
                Our Client experience Manager has shared the requisite details to your registered email id.
                Regards,
                Team Edelweiss
                Helpful
                Found this helpful?
                2 Comments
                Report
                Copy

                Post your Comment

                  I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                  code
                  By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                  Submit
                  K
                  K R Stockbroking
                  from Morbi, Gujarat
                  Oct 23, 2018
                  Report
                  Copy

                  Address: 361001

                  Dear sir,

                  As per your email, as per your instruction, voice logger is compulsory. But there is no any mention in sebi's circular that you people told that what you decide, your company decide, your company collabration with voice logger's company, is compulsory we have to install.

                  As per your instruction, we install voice logger. But the charges you taken, is double than market price. And what we decide to install voice logger, is not allowed by you. So why we can't install our voice logger, while you take double charges for same logger.

                  Further you send bill to ap, is not same charges, while you install same voice logger to all ap. Why this rate of voice logger difference to all ap. Why you give bill to one ap half charges for voice logger, and to another ap double charges for same voice logger, that install by you, or contract giver by you to any company.

                  "how come there are two difference rates for same systems, in which i have been ask to pay rs. 11000, where as you are charging 5900 to someone else!!!"

                  Pls. Clearify and do reply soon...

                  There is no any reply from any one...
                  Still no Any Reply, or no any solution...for above complain.
                  Helpful
                  Found this helpful?
                  1 Comment
                  Report
                  Copy

                  Post your Comment

                    I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                    code
                    By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                    Submit
                    S
                    sikkander badhusha
                    from Madurai, Tamil Nadu
                    Sep 17, 2018
                    Report
                    Copy

                    Address: Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu

                    With reference to the above for your kind information, I finished for last EMI at July month 30th day. After completed EMI, I called in your office not attend the phone calls. I will call 100 times. But not responding your side. Its loan affected for my CIBIL Score. Therefore, kindly close the loan account and send loan closure letter, Take necessary action immediately. Kindly to the need ful
                    Hi,
                    I had bought a term insurance and paid a premium of rs7400. It medical the policy was rejected and from last 3-4 months i am chasing for refund and they are not giving it. Chor and worst insurance company
                    Helpful
                    Found this helpful?
                    1 Comment
                    Report
                    Copy

                    Post your Comment

                      I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                      code
                      By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                      Submit
                      N
                      Neeraj.28
                      from Noida, Uttar Pradesh
                      Aug 22, 2018
                      Report
                      Copy

                      Address: Gautam Buddh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh, 201301

                      Dear team,
                      I have aplay for loan agaist sallary. All documents collected by company representative pranjul his mobile no. Is [protected]. He has show me sanction letter and i have give him signed ecs form and 4-cheques.
                      Any amount loan not credit in my account till now. Why ecs and cheque present in my account without giving me loan. Please check and do the need full about this fraud. Whatsapp conversation screen shot attached.

                      Regards
                      Neeraj kumar
                      +1 photos
                      Helpful
                      Found this helpful?
                      Write a comment
                      Report
                      Copy

                      Post your Comment

                        I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                        code
                        By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                        Submit
                        N
                        Nravineeds
                        from Chennai, Tamil Nadu
                        Apr 26, 2018
                        Report
                        Copy

                        Respected sir/madam,

                        September 27, 2005 joined as financial consultant at bangalore office with anagram stock broking ltd.,. Employee id-1390
                        I have sent already manu emails to [protected]@edelweiss, but there was no response, currently i have no job also, so if i get my pf amount it will be of great help to me, kindly consider this.

                        Do the needful for my pf claim amount.

                        Regards
                        Ravi kumar. N
                        [protected]
                        [protected]@gmail.com
                        With out disbursement rs.7190/- & interest amount rs.460/- was collected hard cash rs.2000+1500+300 total 3800/- in addition to all original documents collected. On pressure cancellation letter handed over please verify and hand over to me.

                        pf claim regarding - Comment #3225542 - Image #0
                        pf claim regarding - Comment #3225542 - Image #1
                        psdeva's reply, Sep 29, 2018
                        Edelweiss - ecs and cheque submitted without loan disbursement
                        Helpful
                        Found this helpful?
                        1 Comment
                        Report
                        Copy

                        Post your Comment

                          I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                          code
                          By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                          Submit
                          M
                          Mohammed Zakeer CEng, MCABE, MIET
                          Jan 10, 2018
                          Report
                          Copy

                          Address: Bangalore, Karnataka, 583227

                          Dear sir,

                          Purchased a online policy from edelweiss and while process of purchasing online, soon after clearing the payment there was an internet interruption which resulted in disconnected process. Money from my account got deducted, however policy purchase could not be completed.

                          Wrote to edelweiss to resolve the issue for a month with continuous follow up email every alternate day, only to see them ignoring, not resolving the issue.

                          Request your assistance in this issue and a strict action to be taken on edelweiss for fraudulent service.

                          Many thanks
                          Zakeer
                          +1 photos
                          Helpful
                          Found this helpful?
                          Write a comment
                          Report
                          Copy

                          Post your Comment

                            I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                            code
                            By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                            Submit
                            A
                            alosarkar9433
                            from Kolkata, West Bengal
                            Dec 18, 2017
                            Report
                            Copy

                            Address: Kolkata, West Bengal, 712203

                            I am alo sarkar my a/c no 21701151 pan no aznps5053r. I am a on line trader my rm is goutam naskar. I come to know my rm he told me that edel weiss has made a new system that in each transction any no of share i buy & sell then rs 50 to be paid. It is really not possible to pay me such a very small trader. I shall be glad if you exampted me from this system then i start trading again. Thanking you. Alo sarkar.
                            Helpful
                            Found this helpful?
                            Write a comment
                            Report
                            Copy

                            Post your Comment

                              I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                              code
                              By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                              Submit
                              T
                              Tarun Rai Choudhuri
                              from Port Blair, Andaman and Nicobar Islands
                              Oct 15, 2017
                              Report
                              Copy

                              To
                              Edelweiss web service limited
                              Edelweiss house off cst road
                              Kalina mumbai-400098
                              Dear sir
                              Since its inception 6 years back your agent approached me of opening a/c for issue o[censored]nited bank shares but nothing is done in this respect, there is no demat a/c opened then. A cheque of large amount - is issued in your favour. I vehemently tried to contact him. But he could not be traced. Recently i find some message from your end about the trading of shares.
                              On[protected] i noticed a message in my mobile about the trading
                              A/c-ex323584 and the fund balanceis rs 3273.06. I am astonished to find the balance is reduced to great extent last 6 years you could
                              Not informed me about this
                              You have arbitrarily opened e mail id in my name which i have come to know through my mobile on[protected] password
                              Is also at your choice
                              Hence fourth i do not want to continue the trading a/c and the balance to be credited in my s/b a/c[protected] with united bank of india howrah ifsc code-utbi0how 117.
                              Please do it earliest so that the balance to be credited my s/b aic
                              Yours faithfully
                              Tarun rai choudhuri i natunpara hanshkhali pole
                              Dt[protected] p. O-danesh sk lane howrah-711109
                              Helpful
                              Found this helpful?
                              Write a comment
                              Report
                              Copy

                              Post your Comment

                                I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                code
                                By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                Submit
                                K
                                kuldeep85
                                from Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh
                                Sep 5, 2017
                                Report
                                Copy

                                Address: 226001
                                Website: JAGO GRAHAK JAGO

                                I did not open my account in edelwiss but before 5 to 6 year i continue recieving mail from that side i have complaints in jago grahak jago and complaint id is 9955748 and they advised me to file a case from consumer court but did not want to charge any case i want simply plz close my account asap and if somebody is responsible for this so company will take against that person.
                                If no body will help me simply i will charge a case of fraud from consumer court. And my clint code 1102728 and name is kuldeep kumar tripathi.
                                +1 photos
                                Helpful
                                1 other people found this review helpful
                                1 found this helpful
                                Write a comment
                                Report
                                Copy

                                Post your Comment

                                  I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                  code
                                  By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                  Submit
                                  A
                                  Alka Vishwakarma
                                  from Noida, Uttar Pradesh
                                  Aug 28, 2013
                                  Report
                                  Copy

                                  Sir, I deposited advance to m/s edelweiss company for trading, for low brokerage they said we will return it money i[censored] closed a/c. I applied for open demat a/c with edelweiss before 2yrs. I paid 10 thousand rs as advance brokerage to them I used only 2000 rs. From last year I talk to them to closed my a/c and return remaining brokerage 8000.00 rs. They are saying we will not policy to return remaining amount. Pls suggest how can I get my money from them. Regards Alka
                                  Helpful
                                  Found this helpful?
                                  Write a comment
                                  Report
                                  Copy

                                  Post your Comment

                                    I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                    code
                                    By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                    Submit
                                    M
                                    Marudhappan
                                    from Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu
                                    Jan 10, 2013
                                    Resolved
                                    Report
                                    Copy
                                    Resolved

                                    Address: Chennai, Tamil Nadu

                                    i was a/c with coimbatore edelweiss through sriram. He collected deposit from me Rs 100000.
                                    Few days that amount was gone.I ask to sriram replied its Advance Brokerage.Then i fight to him arrange police support then i known Rs 50000 for commission for Sriram and his team.Finally he commited refund 1 lack.Please don't open a.c Edelweiss team.They are fake group

                                    Marudhappan - Chennai
                                    Aug 13, 2020
                                    Complaint marked as Resolved 
                                    Helpful
                                    Found this helpful?
                                    Write a comment
                                    Report
                                    Copy

                                    Post your Comment

                                      I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                      code
                                      By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                      Submit
                                      S
                                      suniljena1985
                                      from Mumbai, Maharashtra
                                      Feb 27, 2012
                                      Resolved
                                      Report
                                      Copy
                                      Resolved

                                      Address: Maharashtra


                                      Dear ,
                                      My name is Sunil jena & i am having an edelweiss trading account withe ID no 465503.
                                      My RM ( Sarfaraj ) called me & informed me theat theere was a launch of IDFC bond & for theat i have to pay only Rs.5000 & remaining funding would be done by edelweiss & for thee same i was told to fill a form & give a cheque amounting to RS.5000 which i provide to him & thee date mentioned on thee cheque was of 20 Jan 2012.
                                      later on on 29the of jan 2012 my RM called me & told theat my application has been rejected by edelweiss & thee cheque was not processed, when i ask him to return thee cheque he told you will be getting it back therough courier but on 07 feb 2012 i received a message stating theat thee cheque has been bounced due to insufficient fund & charge of Rs.386 was debited from account as cheque bounce charges.
                                      when contacted to Sarfaraj, initially he told theat he dont know how thee cheque got deposited & later on he told theat thee company had deposited all thee cheques irrespective of applications processed or rejected & now he is saying theat i have to pay thee charges & notheing can be done...so i would like to know how can edelweiss encash thee cheques for rejected application & also thee cheque was deposited & returned on 07 feb 2012 & till 06 feb 2012 i was having sufficient balance in my bank account..does theis mean theat you withe cooperation of hdfc are knowingly depositing thee cheque when theere is not sufficient balance available...Its highly unacceptable as thee date mentioned on cheque was of 20 jan 2012 & it was deposited on 07 feb 2012 theat too witheout thee consent of thee customer & for a rejected application...i want complete explanation for thee same...also i want to know why thee cheque was deposited on 07 feb 2012 if thee date mentioned was 20 jan 2011 also what about thee charges theat is debited from my account & who would be responsible for theat & who is going to pay theat charges to...i want complete explanation for theis issue..
                                      Expecting a quick & positive response from your side

                                      Regards,
                                      Sunil Jena.
                                      Mo. [protected]
                                      Aug 13, 2020
                                      Complaint marked as Resolved 
                                      This is continues happened in Coimbatore Branch – Edelweiss Financial Advisory Ltd
                                      Branch Head SriRam Madavan duty only blaming customer money collect more advance Brokerage with out client knowledge .Also he regularly doing PMS client money. Also doing some other activity in side office .Don’t open any ac in Coimbatore edelweiss money not safe also some illegal activity going on
                                      Helpful
                                      Found this helpful?
                                      1 Comment
                                      Report
                                      Copy

                                      Post your Comment

                                        I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                        code
                                        By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                        Submit
                                        S
                                        sheik hassan
                                        from Mumbai, Maharashtra
                                        Sep 14, 2011
                                        Resolved
                                        Report
                                        Copy
                                        Resolved

                                        Address: Mumbai City, Maharashtra

                                        the company cheated me..

                                        (1)
                                        first company agent did'nt clarify about advance service plan.
                                        he told me that on pay Rs 4950 in advance he charge me Rs 20 per lot for option and future.but actually he charged me as Rs 70 per lot.
                                        {
                                        let me clarify.....
                                        on paying advance brokerage company cut Re 1 from main account and 19 Rs from Advance Brokerage.But actual company verify dat on advance brokerage u have got Rs 1.8 crore transactions means.
                                        suppose if i buy option of nifty
                                        call 5000 @ a rate of Rs 50. that means i have to pay (50*50)= Rs 2500 and brokerage=Rs 20 per lot. ie mean i make a transaction of Rs 2500 but according to you my transaction is (50*5000)=Rs 250000.
                                        if i divide Rs 1.8 crore by Rs 250000 den i am able to get only 72 slot according to you at brokeage Rs(1+19). after dat my transacyion limit is over.This deal is not given by u at the time of account open.
                                        Actually u have charged me 5000/72=Rs 70 per lot.
                                        }

                                        (2)
                                        After that online website service is also very poor,due to this i had lost a big amount .And he also responding late of my mail .
                                        Aug 13, 2020
                                        Complaint marked as Resolved 
                                        HI ..

                                        I would like to share my exp with Edelwise.The Staff in CHD is totally unskilled and pathetic.
                                        They opened the account with zero charges and when account has been opened then they deduct the charges without any prior communication.
                                        They are not making the faith in the market. Now I am going to close the account. This happened with my friend also.

                                        My Concern is that I have already my account with another broker then why I will go with edelweiss if they are no any special service.

                                        Regards
                                        Ashish Jain
                                        [protected]
                                        Helpful
                                        Found this helpful?
                                        1 Comment
                                        Report
                                        Copy

                                        Post your Comment

                                          I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                          code
                                          By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                          Submit
                                          S
                                          suniljena19
                                          from Pune, Maharashtra
                                          Jun 17, 2011
                                          Resolved
                                          Report
                                          Copy
                                          Resolved

                                          Address: Thane, Maharashtra

                                          At the time of account opening i was told that to give a post dated cheque which i agreed on the assurance that it would be cleared only after my consent,but later on without my knowledge it was cleared also my account had been open from last 20 days but still i have not got got the welcome kit & when i try to call the sales person he is not answering my call...it too much frustrating for a customeer
                                          Aug 13, 2020
                                          Complaint marked as Resolved 
                                          Helpful
                                          Found this helpful?
                                          Write a comment
                                          Report
                                          Copy

                                          Post your Comment

                                            I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                            code
                                            By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                            Submit
                                            B
                                            bagthasingh
                                            from Mumbai, Maharashtra
                                            Nov 3, 2010
                                            Resolved
                                            Report
                                            Copy
                                            Resolved

                                            Address: Tamil Nadu

                                            I wanted to do some stock trading by joining Edelweiss and paid their prepaid brokerage of Rs 2450. But, even after 2 months, my account was not opened. Though I repeatedly enquired about this, I was asked to wait forcouple of days. But, my account never got opened after waiting for 2 months.
                                            Atlast after 70 days, my account was opened and they asked a margin cheque for Rs1500. They said my cheque value will be credited to my de-mat account in Edelwiess. But, that amount was not credited to my account till now, though the money was debited from my bank account.

                                            Is it possible to get the money back? Is there any forum to compalin about this cheating?
                                            Aug 13, 2020
                                            Complaint marked as Resolved 

                                            EDELWEISS — not transparent

                                            i was a new client in edelweiss company for trading.their predict was not perfect and without my permission they play with my money.i loss around 60k with in 5 month.please dont believe this group and workers.
                                            Helpful
                                            Found this helpful?
                                            1 Comment
                                            Report
                                            Copy

                                            Post your Comment

                                              I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                              code
                                              By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                              Submit
                                              V
                                              Visra143
                                              from Hyderabad, Telangana
                                              Aug 10, 2010
                                              Resolved
                                              Report
                                              Copy
                                              Resolved

                                              Address: Mumbai City, Maharashtra

                                              Please find my below mail sent to Edelweiss on 10th Aug 2010........

                                              Dear Tarun Sharda,

                                              This is the worst & useless response from Edelweiss team...
                                              Our Agreement at the time of filling the form is as follows before opening the Trading Account...

                                              In the below mentioned blue bold words promised by you i.e. Mr. Tarun Sharda...

                                              1. Bank Account - Opening with HDFC or YES Bank - Agreed & Accepted by Tarun Sharda...- With out Opening the Bank Account to me who the hell said to deposit the Cheque with out my permission..... ???????????????????????????????????

                                              2. On 3rd Aug 2010 before i am moving to Hyderabad i clearly mentioned that i am not return till 24th Aug 2010, & requested to don't deposit the Cheque. - Agreed & Accepted by Tarun Sharda. - who had given you the permission to deposit the cheque with out my permission......???????????????????????????????????

                                              3. I clearly said to you that i have some doubts, with out getting clarity, i don't want to open Account with Edelweiss. - Promised me that you are supposed to bring your RM on 4th Aug 2010, failed to bring him on said date. -with out informing to customer how you will deposit the cheque....?????????????????????????

                                              Actually i came for a medical treatment at hyderabad, i sent my brother to withdraw money, where as insufficient funds in my SBI Account.......

                                              There are two things..............................
                                              I don't want to bare This mistake.......

                                              Here I am mentioning my SBI, Dadar (E) Branch A/C No : [protected]
                                              Before EOD of 11 Aug 2010, The deposited Cheque Amount Rs. 8458/- needs to be deposited in my Account...

                                              By HOOK or CROOK the above said needs to be closed....
                                              Other wise i don't want the account with EDELWEISS............

                                              Regards,

                                              Vishnukanth Vinayak Chiluka,
                                              [protected]Andhra Pradesh),
                                              [protected]Mumbai).
                                              Aug 13, 2020
                                              Complaint marked as Resolved 
                                              Introduction



                                              This letter was written by Mrs Neela Wickramasinghe to Mr Harrison, in 2001, opposing to keep Passover and God’s feast with the unbaptized 800 Indians which he invited to PCG. In 2001, proving that this involvement is against God’s word which broke the marriage covenant, and she has written with proof, exposing the lies. To this day, this sin was not repented of. This fulfills the “Bamah” sin mentioned in Ez 22: 29.,





                                              Dear Mr.Harrison,

                                              2001 Nov

                                              As you requested, hereby, I would like to bring to your kind attention that the work of God in India and Srilanka is stagnant at the moment. Many baptized members had the impression that they are isolated and being neglected, their questions are not being answered and receipts are not regular etc.and many other complaints were made especially about Mr.Kumar. During the FOT, all the members had come together and had discussed about their problems and as the lay members should, they brought these things to me for a solution. These things were bothering me for the last two years. I did not think the seriousness of these until you were hesitating to pay the office rent in Srilanka.

                                              I could see how Satan is attacking the little flock in India specially. I do not mind if it is God’s will, but if it is Satan’s work, we must really look into the problems, I think you will agree. I will write more about these things in the other letter, which you are going to show to Mr.Flurry. I will write more about Mr.Kumar in this letter. First of all let me say, that my intentions are not to judge, accuse or look down on anybody. But the day that God gave me the responsibilty as a minister and as you have given me authority over Sumanth, I think it is my duty to let you know about these things. Without wasting your valuable time, let me get to the point.

                                              I would like to remind you that we all were very excited when you met Sumanth and when we found out that there are 800 members willing to join the PCG. We trusted Sumanth wholly. But you and I had doubts. You wanted to start the Indian work somehow and to register the church in India so we forgot about him misleading us with many lies. You said we’ll start the work and God will show us whether he is genuine etc…So you decided to give a chance to him.

                                              Just because these people keep sabbath, and from Church of God, from Sardis era, as a whole group, could we accept them to pcg????We only had Sumanth’s word. There were no translators so whatever he said, we had to believe. We never thought somebody could deceive us so much. As you read on all the evidence, you will see how Kumar learned few things about the WCG and claimed to have associated with wcg for 20 years reading the “Plain Truth” etc.. Pcg is a very unique group with its teachings and doctrines, and God will not absorb 800 at once was a question I had from the beginning.????? Then I let you be the judge as it was my duty, to obey God’s govt….. Remember both o[censored]s had many questions?

                                              Another question was 14 ministers given certificates of ordinations without even getting to know them and their willingness and eligibility. Again we only had Sumanth’s word. When we think of this, looks like it is a serious mistake .Do they have the knowledge as we do? Can anyone approach them and ask a question about our teachings? Even Sumanth himself? You have told him to send you the questions if anyone asks. That means you were not sure whether he could answer. Can you take any of them to a ministerial conference if the church had enough money? Especially a minister like Rupa’s brother who is a driver who cannot even read the bible properly? But when we first began, we did not know they were like that. We only had Sumanth’s word. The good thing is we are still in the learning process. You see, just to encourage you, let me remind you about people like Mr.Avila, Mr.Tkach, they were in the church a long time, they were called by God, all the evangelists in the WCG etc.., and God Himself is learning about us and just because they fell away it is not God’s fault, Mr. Flurry was not wrong to have Mr.Avila, Mr.Armstrong was not wrong to have Mr.Tkach ordained as the Pastor Gen., etc.. So we also do not know at the beginning how they will turn out. Anyway, what we must do is, if I may say so, is we learn from our mistakes and when God reveals an iniquity of someone, then we must do something about it. Otherwise, if we let these problems persist, then God will hold the people responsible for not taking action. Also, if we let these things keep on happening, we ourselves will fall. And God cannot add or He will not bless that particular area. And I think that is what has been happening. So do not get discouraged, all o[censored]s are praying for this to be solved, and God will bless us for learning from our mistakes.

                                              We were really disturbed from this when you assigned him to give two sermons. Neela argued with me saying this man cannot give sermons in God’s church and she did not want to come to the feast even. I still have not answered her question. Because I know I have to obey you even though I knew this man cannot give sermons. Then Neela had fasted and prayed and the same night Sumanth called and said he is not coming to the feast. Then only Neela agreed to come to the feast. Deepak and Basil also were planning to not to come to the feast if he was coming. I know others will follow too. I was helpless and could not answer Neela’s question. The reason why the brethren cannot accept him as a minister was, last feast when he came for two days, he said a prayer. He did not know to end the prayer, he had to ask in Jesus’ name. Everyone was waiting to say amen, he had finished without ending properly. Everyone heard and kept quiet. Everyone has had questions about him being a minister even though they did not say anything from that day onwards.

                                              Here are some of the complains the brethren were saying, About the prayer, when he visit Hyderabad, soon after you leave, he invites many outsiders to have dinner and pay from the church account. You knew about this. At the last passover, he and Mannaseh and Prakash and Bezaleels kept together, the bread was distributed like literature. No reverence at all, he and Mannaseh have asked Prakash to find the best hotel in town and when they went to the hotel it was full, so they had gone to another and had eaten meal spending nearly 10, 000 rupees. Then when sleeping, him and Mannaseh were hugging. According to Prakash. That is why he thought he is homosexual. The money was paid by a credit card made to the church account. He was late to the passover meeting because trying to find the best hotel, he has not sent receipts properly. He has been collecting building fund after I even told him not to do so., He could not be contacted whenever the brethren wanted, he had not called to find out how they were doing even once in a while, Last passover he has told Bezaleels that he will come to Hyd., and then told them to come to Bhimavaran, then again changed and said he was coming, then again changed and told them to come and the day before the passover, he had told them not to come and he cannot come either and cancelled the passover and told them to keep alone. All the time, when I called, he was no where to find. He had told you that he was with the father in law. Even if my wife is sick, I will keep the passover with the brethren. Would not a real minister of God????? Even after the passover when I called, he said he had it in the American centre as I instructed him. When I called from Bombay, he was not to be found. Just because your father in law is sick, that is not a reason to not to keep the passover. Can you blame Bezaleels for being upset that they could not keep the passover? Their questions were not answered. Money has collected to send church CDs. Not a word about it ect…. Let me not waste any more time.

                                              They say they did not want to send their tithes to him. Dr.Bezaleel has collected his tithes and had given to you. You have told them to give it to Sumanth. They were upset but did as they were told. When you went this time, you had asked Mr.Azariah how much is a printer? He has told the most expensive one is about 6, 000. You also have told them that Sumanth quoted Rs.20, 000. You had told Deepak, that how come the phone calls are so expensive that Sumanth’ phone bill is too high or something. Then you have told something about Sumanth misleading you with receipts to Dr.B. These things confirmed their suspicions. Because they feared the disfellowshipment had kept quiet without asking you. Bella was very happy that she did not give that 50.000 to him. So when everyone came together in the feast, all were talking about him and complained. You have told them that before you leave in August, you plan to buy a printer for Sumanth. I did not know otherwise. They asked, knowingly that Sumanth is cheating, why you are still taking no action and still buying things for him when he does not do anything like taking care of the brethren, and keeping him as a minister etc…???? I have the same question myself. And I do not have the answer. They asked, how come his phone bill is high, his ministers are in villages and do not have phones, who is he calling? He does not call us. When these things, I tried to bring to your attention, you are accusing me of turning the brethren against Sumanth and you have told Neela also that and the last time when you called, the first question you asked was how dare you accuse a minister of God. I was patiently waiting just to please you and obey you. Not that I and Neela ever accepted him as a minister. Neither did Basil and Deepak, because they saw the biodata and Sumanth’s passport showing that his real age when they were here in Srilanka . So they did not accept him as a minister either.Neither did Prakash, because Prakash went through that experience two years ago and he said that is why he will not send tithes to him.

                                              We watched him cheating God’s money, cheating you and the brethren who did not know about him etc… Mrs Azariah has told we saw the WCG ministers fall away and now the pcg., and where to go? What to do? Stanis Laus told me to not to tell his newly converted parents as they will be upset. Everyone agreed to not to send tithes even you tell them. This is very serious and this will go to Mr.Flurry and I am glad you have told Neela that you told Mr.Flurry about this already.

                                              In Bhimavaran, Rupa said they did not keep the feast even last year. Not this year either. She would not tell where Sumanth is. Sumanth called after some time and said he is in Visakapatnam. If he had gone there, which is 6 hours away from home, would not he tell his wife? They both hid from us where he was. When he called he said he went at 4 in the morning and his brother said he was in their house with the father when he was taking a shower around 8 in the morning. Whom to believe? I found a letter written by him to a catholic church signing his name as reverend Sumanth Kumar, which a copy enclosed. Both Deepak and Dr.Bez. were witness to these things. Then, we found the tapes in their envelopes, unopened. We opened them to see the ministerial conference tapes. Who is the pcg minister who does not want to hear what the prophet has to say. We cannot wait to get tapes. When we asked him, he said he got two sets. How does he know the same tapes are inside unless he opens them and see? Then I asked Rupa about the last hour. She did not know anything about it. Should these things happen in the pcg ministry? I have no idea, knowingly about this man’s character, you still let paying him and pay the rent and sending tithes and giving everything he is asking such as the printer just two months ago. What happened to the 100, 000 rs., he had one week before the feast? He has not given me an answer. You have told Bombay brethren that there are 100, 000 in the church account when you visited. Deepak has explained in his letter., and during the feast, when we went to get 20, 000, he says he does not have any money. Can you blame the brethren for being so upset? Yet you blame us for turning the brethren against this man. You have confirmed their suspicions. Not us. I plead you to understand that. I do not want to take the blame for something that I never did. We still hold the brethren from writing to Mr.Flurry. Everyone is waiting for you to take action.


                                              We listened to Mr.Flurry’s and Mr.S flurry’s min.con.tapes. Mr.Flurry’s second part of searching deeper things says we need growth but not to look for numbers. We need to clean out problems. We must be honest. We cannot be people pleasers. Ministers must keep the law and be an example. What example has he given to members? Enough to reject him? Further Mr.F. says cannot let week deacons and elders cause problems so that they can keep numbers up otherwise God cannot bring more. In Mr.S.F’s tape “What to look in an asst.”, he gives many qualifications that none Kumar has. Also to test, prove an elder. So for the last two years what are his fruits?

                                              After your phone calls made me further examine myself why God wants us out. Why God’s govt., does not want to pay the rent and close down the office in Sri Lanka and at the same time He Has blessed me with a job that pays a higher salary and sabbath off and with accomodation., phone and accom., even for Neela etc………. When I deeply thought about all those things, Neela and I came out with these thoughts:- It is not God who wants us out. But satan. We were planning to move out when you were hesitating to pay the rent. Then all of a sudden it came to my mind that if we leave we are leaving God’s children in Sumanth’s hands. He will play havoc. No way. So we really started looking into this matter deeply. See how much God Has revealed about him. He is known to one church as an evangelist, to another one father, to another as reverend {which we have a photo} and so on. Further, in the ucg article, it is Mr.Samuel and Israel seated. {Second left and first right.} So he cannot lie. But in page 14, he denies that any of the pcg members or ministers had gone to this conference. Go to the ucg web address I sent earlier and see the photo of the elders . How can he lie to God’s ministers like this? So now it is clear to me that satan is the one who is really trying to send me away and bring in his demonic ministers. I do not know how you cannot see this. Even last week when you called Neela had told you that she is planning to go to America. And you had said it is good. So Is this really a satan’s trick to not to renew the Sri Lankan office rent and send me away and destroy the work of God in this part of the world? Does God want such a minister in His church to look after His children? Does He want such a person in His church as a director? Can you blame me or any other member trying to reject him?

                                              You know he lied about his age adding 10 years because his father told him to do so to look like more experienced. He told you that . Then he lied about his income saying that he does not have a job and only his wife works. Later we found out that he is the director of many charitable {at least four} organisations and he charges 50 rs., where as others charge 200. Then he lied about his education saying he has a degree in history and so on . Now he change that also. This was from the beginning. You told us to keep confidential. So we did. Then you told Neela we just have to forget it because gentile ministers do this kind of things. We cannot keep this any longer. I do not think God would like that. Neither will Mr.Flurry.

                                              Neela was upset after you were hesitating to pay the rent for the Srilanka office. You had said that the rent is too much. Let me remind you that only once before you sent money to pay the rent, last year, we paid from the money we collected from here. Only twice you have sent money, the other time for Chloe to go to the camp. Also this August. We rented this place three years ago for the same amount and after three years, still the landlord has not raised the rent like anywhere in the world does because we are nice to him and we give no problems. Bhimavaran office rent is double, let me remind you. Anyway we were planning to go to America soon after we came to Srilanka what stopped us was the work of God. When Satan tries to get rid o[censored]s, we have decided to fight. God will correct the problem. We know that the money allocated to these two countries going only to Bhimavaran. We knew this was coming.

                                              So Mr.Harrison, when the brethren brought these things to my attention as they should, I think what I should do is to check whether these things are true and to bring to your attention so you could take a decision. Actually, I did not go to Bhimavaran to check him out, but I went to ask him why he does not answer my calls, and to greet personally, those members, and mainly to get about Rs.20, 000 from the bank account. I was under the impression that he is keeping the feast their with 60 members as he told and I though I will meet him. If I knew he was not at home, I would not have gone. But I was going to confront him with the accusations the brethren brought out to me, such as why he has not sending the receipts properly etc… having authority over him, and taking two witnesses as the scripture says. So here I am doing my duty. I hope you see that. I pray you see that. I am not taking any action against your decisions. Please understand that.
                                              What he told you and I are contradictory all the time. Sometimes I felt that purposely he told you the correct thing and he told me the wrong thing when I complained, I would look like the wrong person. Such as paying the rent for the office in Bhimavaran for two years. He told us that and he would have told you the correct thing.

                                              Remember when he first came, he had already named his church PCG? He already had biodata of all the ministers printed in church letter head? So we were excited and thought giving a chance. This went out of hand.

                                              That November he said he already had the feast. And you paid rs60, 000? He did not stop from there. He organized a pyc camp and told you to send t-shirts etc…? He claimed that he bought the video camera for the church and asked you to pay rs.30, 000? You paid. And actually he had bought in England when he went to ucg feast in 1998? But you paid that money? Then you paid rs.60, 000 to buy a fax machine which he never bought and pocketed the money? When we asked he said it is under repairs and never saw it? All the money God’s people had given to God, was spent in vain in three conferences he organised. He does things and tell you to pay and you pay. Just this last conference he had bought a bed for rs.60, 000. That bed was not there this time. He would have rented or would have borrowed it. That money too is gone. Then for printing those articles of what is pcg?? Then he said he is renting the upstairs for rs.60, 000. Even in Bombay, at beach front, Mr.Azariah’s beautiful house was rs.30, 000 a month. We did not believe it. But you paid. For a month for the rent and to maintain the Indian office, rent 6, 000.00
                                              . Phone bill average 15, 000.00
                                              Allowance usd300 13, 500.00
                                              34, 500.00 which is in srilankan rs.70, 000. This is only for one month Our whole year rent is rs 84, 000. That is for 12 months.
                                              Satan has succeeded bringing him into the ministry list. The first office mentioned in the ordination list was bhimavaran. While he was spending all this, you could not afford to pay dollars 60.00 and send us the KOD videos. Ron started sending us. We took those each time to the feast. Everyone watched. We show them to living church and global church people too. Satan sent his minister to steal God’s money and showing that he is doing a great job and neglecting the brethren. You have told everyone even us, that Sumanth is doing a great job there. Everyone would like to know his good works. Even after this feast, after we found out about him and let you know, he called you and poisoned you saying we had gone while he was away. Who told him to be away. He called and said he is keeping the feast with 60 people. That is why I went. Also he said bad things about Dr.Bezaleel. You believed him completely and called us and accused Neela and me for dividing the church. You took his side knowingly that he is a liar and a thief. The only question to us and to the brethren is why you are covering for him. And there are so many other things I just do not have time to write.
                                              To bear fruits we must sow first. How can God give growth when satan’s minister is here.
                                              _
                                              He told you that when we asked why there were not many members gathered as he claims there are 80 people gathering for sabbath at his office, he told you that they do not like white people. And he told me that the local police do not like big gatherings. Then how can they meet for every sabbath?

                                              Bhimavaran Andra Pradesh is the Bible belt for India. They accept anyone coming with a gospel teaching. They share their beliefs commonly. That is why it is not wrong to go to any meeting with any group. Also charity work. Like Mr.Hubert and Sumanth doing charity work. . But do they have the pure religion? Like we do? Should not we be more serious? About our teachings? Should we be more concerned about the numbers? The quantity or the quality? We must practice what we preach, beginning from the ministry.

                                              Sumanth, I think has different ambitions in life. Not to be a PCG minister, but a minister in any church that pays him.

                                              Let us check one by one from the beginning: - Please see the attached pages as I explain.

                                              Pg 4 and 5. …1 to UCG, 2 to catholic organisation in Austria, fax… 3 to saxhum trust and 4.. To catholic organisation phone. Few calls to you, few to me. And all the others are for other organisation that has nothing to do with our church. . Altogether Rs.10, 000 worth calls, And this is only two months bill. I remember you telling that his mobile phone bill one time was rs.20, 000. Total calls: 169. For you and for me 35 and all the other calls are made long distance and foreign calls to other organisations asking for money. In Bhimavaran there are not any members who have phones in those villages and this is only one bill. All the other times he was spending church money to pay for all those calls. Will a real God fearing minister in the pcg, ever do such a thing?

                                              Pg 6…. This is the newletter, Ucg. 4, 000 members in all for Sumanth’s father. These four thousand were divided by the father between the three sons. Vara Prasad, John Benton and Sumanth. Much of the church administration done by him. Oldest minister here says 65, but we were told he is 80. As Mr.Samuel and others claim that they were in the WCG. never in the history of the WCG, they never kept the passover in the morning. If they were really in the WCG, they would have known the real time.

                                              Pg 7…They were showing the poor people. Trying to stir up there emotions to get money. On the sabbath day, they were going to take food and clothes, which is another thing wcg never taught. For 20 years, they claim to be receiving the Plain Truth. Sumanth’s father is saying to ucg ministers, now we would like to learn everything from you. If they were reading the Plain truth for 20 years, why do they have to learn now? He says he wants to begin many more churches in India. Not God but him. He confirms that he has alsready named 6 congregations for ucg. Without even asking ucg first, he has already named. Just like Sumanth did, When he came to Srilanka, he already had all the ministers photos and biodata on printed paper (PCG) pages 12 and 13 for example. When he came to Srilanka, you have not accepted him as even a member. Then only you said you will appoint him as the contact person. So the whole family works like that.

                                              Pg 9….. Second educational project…Sumanth is the Director. Until we found this out in the last conference we did not know that he is the Director. You knew his wife teaches, But he said he has no income. Here he says he has a masters degree. In pg 12, our pcg paper, he says he has a degree in history and sociology. Last week when I called, he said he has a degree in computer not anything else. So he lied about his education, by showing he does not own any schools or any work, he lied about his income.

                                              Here, they are mixing with the seventhday adventists.If they were reading and believed in the palin truth, they would not do this. This is the common practice in these villages to share their religious views. All of the holy days not understood. The day of trumpets, atonement, and the feast of tabernacles will be kept this year. That means they were not keeping these holy days at all. They have no understanding in God’s plan. If they and Mr/Samuel and others claim to have read the plain truth and associated with the wcg, they would have known these things. Do you remember that Sumanth’s father saying if the ucg pays him 10 dollars, he will join that church. So no money, no church for them.


                                              Pg 10….. This is the letter the UCG minister sent to Mr.Desimon after visiting Bhimavaran. The ucg conference which held in two weeks after our conference. They claimed to be in the wcg., they had asked other sabbath keeping groups as well., they are being cheated too. It was clear to them that Sumanth’s brother Prasad and others were never in the WCG as they claim to be. In the ucg coelders web page, Mr.Samuel is sitting in the photo of the elders. Raja Babu, in the same article, is Sumanth because Sumanth said that was his brother in law, Rupa’s brother. He cannot speak a word of english. How could they converse with the ucg ministers? Mr.Baker said he talked on the phone with this Raja Babu, we know that Sumanth was the one who called ucg with our pcg phone, which is clearly seen in pages 4 and 5.
                                              So changing the name to Raja Babu, he is the one who had gone with Mr.Samuel, sitting in the photo and two other ministers. Further, Mr.Prasad himself told the ucg ministers that Raja Babu joined Mr.Flurry’s group. Read the ucg web article again.

                                              Pg 11…..A letter he has written to Dr.Anup saying that he will be in Assam for the passover. After two years in the church he still does not know that you have to assign us where to go for the passover. He must be planning to go there.

                                              12 a…..His passport copy to show that he really is 29 years now. In page 12 b, he says he was 37 years old. You know after we told you that he really is 27 years old. So he says he was ordained in the year 89. Who would ordain a 17 year old.? Because if he was born in 1972, in 1989, he would be only 17 years old, which Mr.Armstrong would not even baptize. I do not think that Mr.Flurry is aware of this. Could he really be a pcg minister? In this page, he is lying about his age, his education, 80 people gathering on sabbath, {there weren’t even 10 people besides the ministers and their wives last time we were there and out of those 10, five people were teachers of his institute and it was their first day }. He is lying about his experience as a minister to claim that he has 10 years experience, he could have not known Mr.Samueal at that time amd Mr.Samuel himself is not a WCG minister.

                                              Pg 13…. This is Rupa’s younger brother. He claims he is 26 years old. Since he is younger to Rupa, he has to be at least a year younger. Rupa was 24 years old in 1999, when this was written. So how could the younger brother is 26 years old when Rupa is 24 years? Even if he was 23 years old, in 1993, as he claims he was ordained, he should have been 17 years old. Which is against pcg ordination requirements. Do you really think he has read MM, Doc.changes, Govt., and MOA? This man came to the feast last year with Sumanth. Our members had a chat with him. He does not know anything in the bible. Our members told this year at the feast. This is one of the reasons why they were upset. How could a person like this was given an ordination certificate? Including Dr.Bezaleel, Stanis and some others spoke in their language. They were upset from the beginning and did not want to tell us in fear of disfellowhipment. When everything came out in the open this year, this is one of the things they questioned me about.

                                              Now another fact that I must tell you is when we were in Bhimavaran, I noticed, that he does not care for my authority over him. He tells me one thing and he tells you another. The most recent thing was, when I told him to bring money to the feast. He said he is busy with 60 people keeping the feast and he lied and did not obey me. After I went, I wrote a letter asking him to send 20, 000 to the feast site. Not only he did not send the money, he did not even bother to call me to say he is unable to send money. Instead, he called you and complained about our visit. Including telling lies about Dr.Bezaleel. Dr, Bezaleel, I have spent two feasts with him, he is a very nice person. Sumanth does not want him to come to his house because he speak the same language. He has even stopped buying some land after listening to the last hour tape. That dedicated he is. Sumanth is accusing him wrongly.

                                              Pg 14… .. He has sent many letters like this addressing only you. It was I who asked about these things but he is addressing it to you only. Also see page 16, Only your visit is notified to some members. Not even to all. Dr.Anup is one of his favourites because he did not go after the receipts. So Sumanth has notified Dr.Anup of your visit and nothing about me accompanying you. Now in this page, he says his brother has called from his personal phone. The phone number 34568 was the pcg number in January when these calls were made. See page 15 b. The numbers both 34568 and 37859 were used. Either number, he has been calling from were pcg numbers. So he is saying that MrNewton has not observed bills correctly. How dare he accuse me ? Here, he is lying openly. Would a pcg minister do that? He is accusing me of wrong doing. Mr.Samuel is sitting in the ucg photo, may be he used another name. As Sumanth himsel[censored]sed the name Raja Babu. Another lie in this page is…….He claims he handed over that project in 1997, see pages 19 and 20, two letters he has written to Saxhum Trust in June 2001, and June 2001, this year. When he said he has handed over and he has nothing to do with that project anymore, you believed. We quickly called Mr.Mann, who is the trustee, and inquired. He faxed these two letters to show us that he is still the director. Please see those letters in pages 19 and 20. Would a pcg minister lie like that?

                                              Mr.Raja Babu, is receiving the good news magazine……. Why would a minister in the pcg, still receives ucg magazines.? Why would his magazines come to Sumanth’s house? Because Sumanth is receiving and in contact with ucg posing as Raja Babu. Here Sumanth is saying Raja Babu is receiving books from UCG. Why would a pcg minister do such a thing? This time When I went to his house, there were magazines from many churches. He is reading them all and get to know their doctrines and writing to them to join just any church.

                                              Pg 15……. A letter from Mr.Mann, Saxhum Trust, funding Sumanth’s charitable organisation The Immanuel Educational Soc….He has been receiving money from this trust even before 1995, and up to date. In the page14, in Sumanth’s letter to you last week says he no longer receives money from this trust. And since 1997, he is not aware of any activities in this, therefore, he openly lies. In 1999, when he joined pcg, he has received english pounds 10, 395. What a lrge amount that is and we have the deed of that land purchase, it was only 3 installements of rs.26, 000. Which is rs.78, 000. The other money ?????????Don’t know how much he said to trust it was. One pound is rs.63 now. He is associated with Immanuel charitable and Immanuel educational soc…. Which he never told you before joining pcg. All those things we later found out. Turn over to the other page, Mr.Mann says he received a letter from Sumanth which was put in the wrong envelope asking for money from a US organisation. Also, Sumanth was giving the impression of trust is the only source of income. The photographs, accounts are coming but they never check them like we did not check.

                                              Page 17….. He has collecting funds and converting them to US Dollars and forwarding them to you. That is not true. He is giving the wrong impression to members.

                                              Page 18…… photocopies of two envelopes on his desk, writing for charity.

                                              Pages 21, 22, 23, letter from Deepak, as a witness to the visit to Bhimavaran.

                                              Pages 24, 25 26……Altter on his desk, while he was writing this he had left on the dest. Deepak video taped this and put in to the computer and got a print out. Addressed to the catholic church CHALCEDON CHRISTIAN CHURCH, .
                                              24.{1} India Headquarters,
                                              {2} p o box 819, which is pcg pobox, in Vijayawada.
                                              {3} Revd. G.Sumanth Kumar, National President. So Here in the photo, you can see, he is a catholic reverend. He has cunningly given Vijayawada address. Does God want a catholic reverend in His church? He is a Director of the Indian church as you say. Does Mr.Flurry know? Very soon, God will make him know. This is why the whole church in India got upset. Thoroughly disgusted. Their minister is now a catholic reverend. Wouldn’t you be upset? Does not God Have any other to appoint as a Director of His church in India?

                                              {4} Rev.Vara Prasad Ganta. This and number 5 rev. Paul moorthy is his brother and father. Now they are reverends in the catholic church. The family who read the Plain Truth for 20 years, who had UCG meetings, and who said they want to be in the PCG, now catholic reverends. How soon can they change religions. To the highest payee I guess. Sumanth is not just a reverend. bUt The National President of this church. If our members are this upset, how upset would God be?

                                              As you can see, he cannot be in pcg ministry. There are so many more if I can waste our time to write. I hope and pray to God that you do the right thing. As I said earlier, do not be worried. Mr.Armstrong could not have known that Mr.Tkach will lead the church astray neither did Mr.Flurry knew about Mr.Sutcliff and Mr.Avila and many others will turn away so you could not have known either. I was loyal to you in these years even though we suffered a lot. I have not spent God’s money in vain. We bought our own fax machine even after you approved for us to buy anew one..

                                              EDELWEISS — account problem

                                              dear sir,
                                              I have deposited an amount of Rs 2450/- as per their brokerage plan. After submitting the amount my account is not working. now I ant my money back is their any way to collect money from them as they fail to provide their services on time
                                              Edelweiss broaking company is cheating many. They have no transperancy and when you call the customer care they wont respond you properly. Pathetic service. and money eaters.
                                              Edelweiss is best firm for cheating individual by misguiding the information about product . Their motive is to get cheque from someone.create new account. they wont worry about customer money and their growth.

                                              so many peoples are failed to get profit by edelweiss recommended shares and info.

                                              Please aware of many fraudulent activities by edelweiss ltd.

                                              They only focused on edelweiss growth. So don't lose your money by Stupid Edelweiss Cheater.
                                              Helpful
                                              Found this helpful?
                                              4 Comments
                                              Report
                                              Copy

                                              Post your Comment

                                                I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                                code
                                                By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                                Submit
                                                P
                                                prabhat lallubhai gohil
                                                from Mumbai, Maharashtra
                                                Feb 18, 2008
                                                Report
                                                Copy

                                                I PRABHAT LALLUBHAI GOHIL,applay for EDELWEISS,I have alloted 8 share of this compney,but i applay for fully ,but yet i did not get refund of rs 92000/-, i have contect many time but every time i become fool by them ,every time they told me i will get my refund in 10day ,but i did not get it yet18/2/2008, & and they did not give us information of higher othority,so pls help me,my cont. mob [protected], gujart, bharuch
                                                Helpful
                                                Found this helpful?
                                                Write a comment
                                                Report
                                                Copy

                                                Post your Comment

                                                  I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
                                                  code
                                                  By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
                                                  Submit

                                                  Edelweiss Recent Comments