Tata Main Hospital Complaints & Reviews

Dear Sir,

Patient name Runu Chowdhury age 77 yrs under employee of Tata steel was admitted in Tata main hospital at Jamshedpur on dtd.25/03/23, at medicine unit 3B ward bed no -47 .she was undergoing with the problem of IBD, UTi, deficiency in protein calcium, accordingly she was recovering to some extent from the issues from all urine output and but day on 10th April due to inserting of rice food pipe, it got delayed for inserting due to delay by ENT Dr the patient remain with no fluid no liquid diets improper nursing and remain same upto 24hr, her urine out put came down body got dehydrated with symptoms shaking hand, low BP and drousyness, that the Sr doctors so
called expert of TMH Dr..S K Panda & DR.Kunal (Sr consultant) of medicine department didn't taken it seriously the not able to identify the present symptoms of shaking hand and drousyness, Low BP and then they have done the CT of brain consulted to Neuro Dr where the report found no problem in brain CT, the neuro Dr diagnosis to elyspy for shaking hands and started the medicine of elyspy, when the patient responce got more poor then the department doctor take decision to transferred to the HDU unit where after proper investigation by the doctors of HDU department informed
us that patient got dehydrated badly their is no symptoms of elyspy, it ihas happen due to totally negligence if the patient would have shifted earlier we would have taken care of all, but we will try our lable best but patient is very badly destroyed and then after lot of effort HDU doctors could not able to save her Life on 13th April.

My question is When the patient was in critical with multiple problems was detected from the day first she admitted, why the Sr doctors has not shifted the patient to HDU (ICU) unit first .?? when patient was required proper nursing / special care.

At TMH for one nurse assignments is to look after for minimum 15 patients then how a patient will get proper care with poor nursing system..

Sr citizen they need some special care proper treatment / Diagnosis from doctors, instead of the Sr Dr SK Panda was asking from her sixth day to take her home in the her critical conditions.

This is the way TMH medicine some of bad elements of the Sr doctors like S K Panda Dr Kunal rather they need for better credibility from their management to maintain with minimum cost expenses and doing their practises for senior citizens.

ISir, I need compliance against the Sr Doctors named mentioned above for their vital mistakes and hence no senior citizens wii get proper treatment and could survived properly.

Earliest action for the above mentioned matter will be earniestly solicited.

Regards

S k Chowdhury

Dear Sir,
Patient name Runu Chowdhury age 77 yrs under employee of Tata steel was admitted in Tata main hospital at Jamshedpur on dtd.25/03/23, at medicine unit 3B ward bed no -47 .she was undergoing with the problem of IBD, UTi, deficiency in protein calcium, accordingly she was recovering to some extent from the issues from all urine output and but day on 10th April due to inserting of rice food pipe, it got delayed for inserting due to delay by ENT Dr the patient remain with no fluid no liquid diets improper nursing and remain same upto 24hr, her urine out put came down body got dehydrated with symptoms shaking hand, low BP and drousyness, that the Sr doctors so
called expert of TMH Dr..S K Panda & DR.Kunal (Sr consultant) of medicine department didn't taken it seriously the not able to identify the present symptoms of shaking hand and drousyness, Low BP and then they have done the CT of brain consulted to Neuro Dr where the report found no problem in brain CT, the neuro Dr diagnosis to elyspy for shaking hands and started the medicine of elyspy, when the patient responce got more poor then the department doctor take decision to transferred to the HDU unit where after proper investigation by the doctors of HDU department informed
us that patient got dehydrated badly their is no symptoms of elyspy, it ihas happen due to totally negligence if the patient would have shifted earlier we would have taken care of all, but we will try our lable best but patient is very badly destroyed and then after lot of effort HDU doctors could not able to save her Life on 13th April.

My question is When the patient was in critical with multiple problems was detected from the day first she admitted, why the Sr doctors has not shifted the patient to HDU (ICU) unit first .?? when patient was required proper nursing / special care.

At TMH for one nurse assignments is to look after for minimum 15 patients then how a patient will get proper care with poor nursing system..

Sr citizen they need some special care proper treatment / Diagnosis from doctors, instead of the Sr Dr SK Panda was asking from her sixth day to take her home in the her critical conditions.

This is the way TMH medicine some of bad elements of the Sr doctors like S K Panda Dr Kunal rather they need for better credibility from their management to maintain with minimum cost expenses and doing their practises for senior citizens.

ISir, I need compliance against the Sr Doctors named mentioned above for their vital mistakes and hence no senior citizens wii get proper treatment and could survived properly..

Your earliest action for the above mentioned matter will be earniestly solicited.

Thanks

After reaching the hospital they treat the patients after 1hr. This happens everytime i come here for treatment, whether the no. Of patients are less or more they do this everytime.

My husband met an accident was 23rd may admitted with ribs injury in tmh and first 3days he responded well but all of a sudden he was put on ventilation even without information... The doctors in hdu were confused as to wat medicine to given when. Due to rude behavior my husband cut the ventilation code twice. And after questing they gave him heavy dose of sedative medicine from where he could not recover.. They on 8th june did a surgery tracestomy which killed himm..10th morning we were informed he had two cardiac arrest when he had already died...
My husband had given hand written notes stating the doctors r talking bad about the family n him attaching the same
I strongly believe he was compelled to death
We were looted with 6lakh in 15days and our patient was killed

My question how can dis so call doctors do this

Very Bad treatment in TMH, retired employees are not get proper treatment in TMH, TMH management's instructions to the doctor avoid retard patient's diagnosis, my mother suffering from last two years in this hospital not get any relief from this hospital's Doctor or medicine, My mother's name is Srimati Manisha Giri Age 73.Years MR no_05/313653, My father Sri Benudhar Giri is retired person from Tisco tube division, We are very disappointed from Tata Main Hospital,

TMH is very bad hospital in terms of its doctors and services too. My father got fracture in leg and he was admitted to TMH. His leg was bleedingg badly from 2pm to 8pm after that he was taken to operation threater. Till 8pm they were just saying that no OTs are vacant. After the operation was completed by Dr. Vinod Singh clamps and rods were implanted for recovery. After 15 days my dad was discharged and we went every month for checkup and recovery test. The doctors told that it would take time every time when we visited to them. After 6 months they told that we have to do one more operation. When we asked why they told bone has not joint yet. We decided to take him to CMC VELLORE. Docttors of CMC examined and told that the case was made complex by doctors and somehow they managed to make my dad walk on his legs after 6 more months. This 6 months was total waste of time which we had spent under the supervision of TMH.

My father met with an accident on 19th april, 2016. He suffered tremendous leg injury and head injury. He was in conversation with me for 1 hour after being admitted to the hospital (He was talking). After that he was taken for x-ray of his legs without ct scan of his head which was bleeding. After x-rays, he was left unattended for almost 3-4 hours, saline was over, heart line became straight. My family members, called staffs several times, but nobody listened. Finally, my father gave up the fight and left us. My mother too was in that accident and had leg fractured. She wasn't provided a ice bag for the 2nd time. On asking for ice bag, they replied that they only had 1 ice bag in the whole hospital. They also plastered wrong portion of her leg which we got to know after one month when we moved to a private clinic as the pain didn't reduce even a bit.
Had proper treatment and care been taken at that time, my father would have been alive and my mother better than before, both physically and mentally.
There are several more patients being treated unfairly and with utter rudeness.
Please look into this issue with high priority as some people have made it their passion to play with patient's lives.

My younger brother, late vishal chand, aged just 33, who was working as assistant manager, finance with timken india, jamshedpur in jharkhand rushed to the emergency ward of tata main hospital with his driver, biju in the night of 20th may 2011 (10.30 pm) after experiencing chest pain and uneasiness.

2. At the emergency ward, vishal met dr. Atul chhabra who recorded his bp, did an ecg and administered two injections, buscopan, a pain relieving anti spasmodic and rantidine.

3. Vishal’s bp was found to be elevated (150/100), his ecg had major irregularities, as later testified through affidavits by three renowed doctors (On record in court). My brother was obese and we have a family history of cardiac death. My father had died of myocardial infarction in 1991 when he was only 44.

4. Dr. Chhabra did not probe the family history and ignored all major symptoms (High bp, ischemic changes in ecg, obesity and uneasiness) of an impending cardiac arrest and mis-diagnosed the ailment as hypertension with acidity. He recommended tablet alprax (Sleep inducing tabs) at bedtime for 3 days and tab rantac 1*2 (4 tabs) to be taken for 2 days and then follow up in medical opd (On record).

5. Vishal went to office the next day (21st may 2011), experienced chest pain again at 10 am, asked his colleague to rush him to another hospital (He was not satisfied with his visit to tmh the previous night) but before he could meet a doctor, he suffered a severe cardiac arrest, collapsed and died at the opd.

6. Post mortem was conducted the following day (22nd may 2011) and the final p. M report confirmed death due to myocardial infarction (M. I) (Cardiac arrest).

7.in the last one and half year, i have not been able to lay my hands on the true copy of mbbs degree certificate of dr. Atul chhabra, who is still employed with tata hospital.

My brother admitted on 29/10/2010 due to spine injury and he has paralysis in his leg and partial paralysis in hands. Then he was able to respirate and talk smoothly. Dr. F B singh said that he had to implant plates by operation as early as possible. Operation was postponed on 1st november, 2010 due doctor was on leave on sunday. Before operation a doctor said to me that he might been taken to CCU for 4-5 days and it would cost Rs.10000/- per day. I said "ok". After operation he was able to respirate. He was taken to CCU on 1st Nov. after operation. On 2nd Nov morning when all family members are at home and my brother's friend was there the hospital authority had decided to shift him in ward without taking any consent from us and at CCU noticeboard on 9:30 am, 2nd Nov updated my brother's condition was critical. We were happy becoz he was transferred to ward but by afternoon he was feeling uneasy in breathing. We complained it to doctor he swiched off his mobile and not taken any action we were panicked and phone to GM of the hospital and finally doctors came after 4 hours and my brother had been taken to CCU and he was taken on ventilation. From next day doctors' started cursing one Dr.Majumdar said that my brother was never able to walk "uske jeene ka kya fayda"(His life is without value). Whenever i asked him technical question about my brother health their replies were cursing only. After 28 days on ventilation almost and Rs.3-4 lac spent and listening such statement we decided to take risk and decided to shift to Cuttak. On 29th Nov on ventilation we had shifted the hospital authority had not given MRI report and other report the then i was not there. My old aged father went with ambulance to Cuttak when doctor from Cuttak want to talk to Dr. F B Singh he swiched off his phone and he denied to talk. Amazingly ventilation was removed on 2/12/2010 in Cuttak. Doctors of Tata Main Hospital made money from us, we are a middle class family we have taken loans and credit for paying bills and doctors of TMH have done duty of recovery agent only. During CCUperiod in TMH by listening such cursing word my brother tried cutting his ventilated pipe several times. Doctors provoke him to do sucide. These are doctors? and when i was going to Resident Medical Officer for estimate he said it would take 3-4 days b'coz his typist was on leave i[censored] want now u have to go to personal department and arrange a typist. What a funny management he and TISCO's Hospital is unable to arrange a typist.I have seen dengue patients thsoe who are non-employees are 10-20 days in CCU b'coz they(Hospital) are earning from them. This is big Hospital in Jamshedpur. But is it a Hospital?