[Resolved]  Municipal Corporation Of Delhi — Pedestrian's right of passage usurped by the rich and poweful

The Editor
The Indian Express
New Delhi [protected]@expressindia.com

Sir,
The rich and the powerful in Delhi’s affluent residential colonies have with impunity curved out a very substantial part open space meant for the citizens by encroaching upon the footpaths and road space to accommodate their large fleet of cars and, in the name of ‘residents’ welfare associations’, exclusive and fairly commodious ‘security huts’, and all ostensibly for free.

In one of the ethnically exclusive colonies of South Delhi, some people have even gone out of the way to cover the roads/freeways (footpaths) by extending their gates to such an extent that the passersby and pedestrians must walk on the available road space, being deprived of their fundamental right to the use of footpaths endangering their safety.
Quite a few, more powerful and influential than their neighbours, have even beautified the available public space meant for pedestrians by putting ornamental plants and posting their liveried security staff, with their own private guard rooms, by totally ignoring the civic rights of their poorer fellow citizens. And, not only that, their unlimited large fleet of huge imported-costliest-glittering cars most audaciously hinder the pedestrians’ right of free passage by being parked on all sides/spaces-outside the gate, footpaths, roadspace, etc.

And, on top of all this, their uniformed security brigade even have the freedom, temerity and audacity of totally stopping the traffic each time any of the residents in these sprawling and huge houses (in a colony meant for refugees!) leave or arrive at their castles.
The most hilarious part of this is the show of authority twice everyday when the ceremony of “change of guard” of the security detail takes place on the roadspace outside these citadels of power. Even for the President of India, this ceremonial ritual is done inside the Rashtrapati Bhavan premises. And, as far as one knows, the MCD or the DDA allow these facilities and privileges for free.

Is it permissible to wonder as to why the less privileged rate payers must as beasts of burden be compelled to suffer this ignominy and inconvenience while parking space, space for "security huts" and exclusive privilege of secured right of way on public roads would be made available to these rich and powerful in the ex-refugees’ settlements at the cost of the common public at large?

And, why must the latter bear the cost of these freebies?
Was this information helpful?
No (0)
Yes (0)
Aug 13, 2020
Complaint marked as Resolved 
Complaint comments 

Comments

This was indeed a very long awaited move by someone to voice the common public's anguish and resentment in this regard. While there is no doubt the the newspaper will neve publish this letter, at least a consumer activist group or a civil rights group can take up this issue through a much larger platform with the authorities, by way of empowering the ignorant mass of poor citizens of Delhi. Yes, it is indeed true that, in a very prosperous purportedly resettlement enclave for the refugees in south Delhi, a cultural hub of an ethnic group, to whom land was allotted at concessional rates almost tantamounting to free of cost, the naked show of money power has become a most irritating civil issue and this may cause serious disturbances later. A very large part of the free space, road space and footpaths has been simply "acquired" and "forcibly occupied" at will by these influential forces and, that too, not only in the name of their Residents' Welfare Associations (regulating entry/exits into/from these enclosed foefdoms but also "regulating" traffic-all in the name of "security". And, in addition, there is rampant and naked occupation of public land by these people to beautify the surroundings of these ex-refugees' palatial properties and to park their numerous vehicles as well as private security huts outside their own gateways. It is not known if additional municipal taxes are collected from these people who clearly claim and show their privileged status of being more equal than the others.

Is there any way of fighting this menace which resembles the fight against the Maoists?
I have seen the posts. Will the authorities take action? Will the newspaper print the letter to the editor? A big NO. In India, equality is a misnomer. Rich people's children feign socialist and ultra-Left orientation for mileage and for enjoying the pervert pleasure of comfortably watching the gradual extinction of the poor aught in the crossfire of the Maoists and the government security forces-the ultimate goal of the rich and their children who are easily and traditionally acceptable by the gullible public in the role of communist messiahs because of our feudal past.

It is futile and dangerous to wage even a campaign against these white collared, privileged class o[censored]rban rich with their private security to protect them. And it is immoral and inequitable to blame Mayavati alone for exhibiting publicly her wealth, however acquired, since we really are not privy to the source of the wealth and influence of the class of people who are the subject matter of this thread of complaint and discussion.

The Indian people have lost-not because of this class which also is the ruling elite, but entirely because of the fundamentally dishonest and surrogate pseudo-left, of all colours. Since the object is money and political power, as usual.
We would like to know from this site administrator the reply if any received from the MCD on this complaint and also the action started by the MCD. As far as we know, MCD does not care for such grievances and complaints-and, in fact, if anyone is audacious enough to pursue such a path by repeatedly making complaints, the officers and staff of the MCD do not hesitate "to teach a lesson" to the delinquent tax payer. And the MCD Commissioner NEVER responds to any letter or email as he belongs to the IAS. This is the tradition-whether the MCD is in the hands of the Congress or the BJP!

Is it not possible for the https://www.consumercomplaints.in to forward copies of similar complaints and grievances to the MCD and insist upon a response/reply? That will be a great gesture.
Another thing which must be considered and publicised is the restriction by the residents of tiny enclaves within the same locality on the free movement of citizens (including neighbours) by unilateral erection of steel gates and keeping these closed most of the time, all in the name of "security" and thus infringing on the civic rights of fellow citizens. This ostensibly happens with the support of the authorities. Under which Act of Parliament or Article of the Constitution such infringements take place and are being encouraged is not known. What is strange is that, if a neighbour wants to visit his next door neighbour, he has to go all the way round and round to reach his destination as there might be a steel gate erected between his house and that of his next door neighbour! This is a representative picture of a predominantly Refugee resettlement colony in Delhi-the CR Park. It is sad that these gates compel poor Postmen, courier delivery men, vegetable vendors and first-time visitors to wander and hunt for the addresses. We have so many Human Rights bodies, Civil Liberties organisations, etc. who are fighting for the Maoists, the Kasabs, the Afzal Gurus-but is there nobody to protest against the above said instances of disregarding civic rights?
For information of all:
In The Statesman,[protected]

"Rich encroachers
SIR, ~ The rich and the powerful in Delhi’s affluent residential areas have carved out a substantial part of the open space in front of their houses for themselves. They have encroached onto the pavements and roadspace to park their cars. In the name of ‘residents’ welfare associations’, exclusive and fairly commodious ‘security huts’ have come up.
In one of the ethnically exclusive areas of South Delhi, some people have even extended the gates of their houses to cover the pavements. This leaves little or no space for pedestrians to walk. Others have laid out gardens on the roadspace meant for pedestrians. They have even posted liveried security staff who have the temerity to stop the traffic each time any of the residents leave or arrive. This entire area was originally conceived to rehabilitate those who had come over from East Bengal, post-Partition.
In effect, the civic rights of the people are ignored. It is the less-privileged tax-payers who have to suffer. The MCD and the DDA seem to be totally unconcerned.
;Yours, etc., TDS,
New Delhi, 17 May"
This is a very common feature all over in Delhi, in every residential colony, especially in the affluent pockets of the colonies and the exclusive enclaves of the powerful and wealthy people. These include not only politicians', but also retired civil servants' very influential (page-3) people's protected monuments. For all these people, private security co. people stop the traffic flow with impunity several times every day, even during peak traffic hours. Because their cars must have right of way over others'. And the entire foot path in front or on all sides of the heavily guarded properties are littered with their numerous vehicles, security men, security huts, etc. As a result, pedestrians including school going children are compelled to walk on the roads-at full risk to their safety.

Whether these people pay extra and additional taxes to the MCD/NDMC/DDA for this (forcible and illegal ?) occupation of the space meant for all, is not clear. At least, the authorities have never been seen to take any action in this regard, at least for show even. There is one particular property in a South Delhi colony where the roads are not wide at all. Opposite this house also there is a very huge property and both are said to be owned by one person/family with tremendous clout. The entire road in front of these two properties is used as car parking lot by the owner, and the remaining open publis space is entirely occupied by the several security staffs, his menials and security cottage. There is indeed not even walking space on the footpaths around the citadel like house for even a stray dog. And this is merely one/two of such properties in the same locality.

I was myself going to write about this when I saw the first entry on this subject and I felt some release of my pent up frustration. And, I am sure, the newspaper to whom the first grievance was addressed has not and is never going to publish that letter. But, there is at least one forum where we can vent our problems/grievances about which our civic authorities do not care.

They cannot be blamed also, since they are neither allowed the time nor the encouragement to really care for common people. In fact, the commoners must suffer to enable the superior fellow citizens to live in comfort. After all, it is ultimately a question of money power.
The right example of the shameless human rights violation is the House of a VIP at 1451 in Chittaranjan Park in Kalkaji, New Delhi 19. The footpath, the thoroughfare, the opposite building, the footpath of this house-all are fully occupied by the very influential owner's foreign vehicles. The helpless old people and children cannot walk in front of these buildings and his security forcibly push people found meeting others and talking to each other and even staring at the gate with a very large insignia. Yes, the change of guard of the security of this house owner is a very big show, like Rashtrapati Bhawan, stopping all traffic on all sides. Everybody says that the owner runs a university and the IAS/IPS officers' children study free of cost there while the ordinary people have to pay 15 lakhs. That is why MCD and Police also keep distance from this house. But there are too many houses like this in this Bengali colony.
I have been following this topic with keen interest. Will someone please inform us as to the result of these grievances and if ever any authority or company has responded to the posts on this splendid website ? Has the MCD cared to reply? Has this site's administrator taken pains and courage to forward these to the MCD?

Post your Comment

    I want to submit Complaint Positive Review Neutral Comment
    code
    By clicking Submit you agree to our Terms of Use
    Submit
    Municipal Corporation of Delhi
    customer care contact
    Customer satisfaction rating Customer satisfaction rating is a complex algorithm that helps our users determine how good a company is at responding and resolving complaints by granting from 1 to 5 stars for each complaint and then ultimately combining them all for an overall score.
    Read more
    11%
    Complaints
    12476
    Pending
    0
    Resolved
    1409
    Municipal Corporation of Delhi Phone
    +91 11 2652 2700
    Municipal Corporation of Delhi Address
    Dr. S.P.M. Civic Centre, Minto Road, New Delhi, Delhi, India - 100002
    View all Municipal Corporation of Delhi contact information