| Address: 201301 |
| Website: www.icicibank.com/Personal-Banking/loans/home-loan |
From : tina arora,
Sector-29, noida-201301
Dated : 23 jul 2017.
Ms pushpa yadav,
Sr. Mgt desk, icici bank ltd.
This refers to your mail dated 10 jul 2017 in response to my complaint dated 14 jul 2017 against icici bank noida branch, sector 50 regarding mismanagement of our home loan account.
I was quite hopeful that my grievance will be addressed responsibly as was done earlier by ms veena mehta, but it is strange that you didn’t even bother to establish facts regarding this case and have taken the ‘cover-up’ reply as must have been forwarded to you by the branch to be true and have just ‘cut n pasted’ their version in your mail. So, at the outset i express my utter disappointment on the manner in which you have responded to my mail. Please allow me to explain to you once again the facts, in para wise manner so that the misdoings of the branch and their justification bared to the sr mgt.
We are fully aware that the roi opted is ‘floating type’ which means that the minimum rate in currency will be automatically applied to the ongoing home loan. The rate applicable for women borrowers for amount from 30 lacs to 75 lacs is 8.65% since apr 2016 and the branch does not have any valid justification for charging the interest @ 9.25% from us.
The terms like i-base, roi & margin etc which you have tried to explain are well known to me. The fact remains that the final rate offered by the bank to all existing customers, based on benchmark rate and margin associated for floating rate is bound to vary from time to time and it is the duty of branch/bank to expeditiously inform their customers for any change of rate or change in policy related to their current home loan account which was never done.
Also, when icici bank changed its rate @8.65 (I-mclr-1y+0.45%) for women borrowers for amount 30-75 lacs, (And, i must categorically mention it here that no where the icici bank has mentioned anywhere that ibid rates are for new borrowers only and will not apply to existing borrowers), why wasn’t that rate automatically applied to our home loan account as well. The bank has no answers for this. Over that, they had the audacity to say that ‘it is the duty of customers to know of latest policy of rbi or changes in i-base rates reduced by rbi…as if all banks, including icici apply such changes effected by rbi immediately and on the same day, and which should actually happen. There can’ t be a more imbecile reason than what was given by branch, which surprisingly you have re-validated. We are shocked.
You may also check this at your end that whenever the roi were cut down by the icici bank, (From date of disbursement (25.08.15) onwards), the reduced roi was applied at a much later date to our home loan account, by the branch for vested reasons to make good business, at our cost. I have the actual dates when the rates were slashed and these are different from those tabulated by branch and made part of your mail :
I base policy date impact
9.35 05/oct/15 decrease by 0.35%
9.30 01/oct/16 decrease by 0.05%
9.25 03/jan/17 decrease by 0.05%
9.10 28/apr/17 decrease by 0.15%
Which.. Again i must say that you did not verify…
Again, upon change of roi, the option rests with customer whether to reduce the emi or tenor of the home loan. How can the branch decide which option is better for the customer. You have mentioned of 04 reset letters of the branch, dated 07.11.15, 15.10.16, 11.02.17 and 09.05.17 which you have attached to your mail. Did you ask the branch as when have they mailed these letters to us, through email or by post and whether they have any proof of their dispatch. Madam, the fact is that since the date of disbursement i. E. 25.08.15, there has been absolutely no communication written or through mail by the branch. All these letters have been prepared now, as a cover up to their omissions. Again, the branch knows it well and has no answers for it.
You have to understand this that the branch was visited by me in 1st week of dec 2016 to obtain the provisional statement of account for making the declaration for purpose of claiming rebate in income tax for fy 2016-17, during this visit, the br manager & i/c complaint was approached regarding non communication by branch on any matter related to our home loan, which was not heeded to and the branch then was in full knowledge of the revised policy of rbi for customers to opt for migrating to new benchmark mclr system, but no information regarding same was disclosed to us. This also explains the branch’s policy on the ‘customer care’ ….. Does the branch or icici bank have any reason for not disclosing the change of policy to us in dec 2016. Obviously, had we opted for mclr, bank’s business would have been affected and their earning at our cost would have reduced. Isn’t it.
But. Ms pushpa yadav, now since you have declined any assistance to me in manner of waiver of conversion fee or rebate in same, while completely declaring the noida sector 50 branch as clean, i have my doubts now whether our grievance would be addressed in an un-biased and fair manner. I think we will need a re-look on doing business with icici with its current policies, approach to customer care and redressal of grievances and the response of sr mgt. Just for your information we are customers of icici wealth, since last 6 years, of icici bank since last 16 years but it is the first time that we have been jolted out of our misplaced trust on icici banking system.
May i request you to provide following information after due deliberation to help us decide the further course of actions regarding this pending complaint. :-
A) if we opt to migrate to new benchmark mclr system now, keeping in view of our outstanding principal amount, what would be the exact cost for executing conversion agreement?
B) what would be the exact conversion fee plus applicable taxes on principal outstanding?
C) if the partial payment is made to the branch to reduce to outstanding principal to under 30 lacs inr, will the rate of 8.35% apply. (I-mclr-1y or 6m + margin cost)., and lastly,
D) will the rate of 7.85% apply for outstanding principal of below 30 lacs inr. If opted for (I-mclr-1m).
E) any other proposal that you have in mind to motivate us to remain customers of icici bank.
I expect an early reply and redressal from you. With the current vindictive approach of branch, being twice bitten and exposed of their inconsistencies, it will be difficult to get a resolution to any issue raised by us. So in all probability it will be prudent if my grievance is addressed by the md & chairperson or by sr mgt.
We look forward to your positive response.
Sincerely,
Tina arora
ICICI Bank customer support has been notified about the posted complaint.